I agree with your assessment. There was also an anomalous BABIP factor that accounts for some of his less-than-dominating numbers. And there are more underlying positives to take away from 2013, even if he didn't meet MrBrooks' standard for second-year dominaton at the same level ( ie, May ranked 3rd overall in the EL in K/9, and as you noted, increasing his K rate, even as he cut his BB rate dramatically). Having said that, I would probably drop him along the cusp of the top 10 now, with Polanco, Santana, and possibly Gonsalves nudging slightly ahead of him, leaving May tied or slightly ahead of Gonsalves for #9 or #10 ( I would drop Kepler out of the top 10, too, as he's destined for another year in CR to get firmer answers on his health and production...and Felix Jorge should get a big bump from up from #20, a big winter ball season for him in the DR might change the rankings quite a bit, too!). Coming back to May, he definitely appears to be a good listener and learner and appears to publicly demonstrate a cerebral approach on what it's going to take for him to reach the majors, this apparent coachability was demonstrated in his successful adaptation to the Twins SP philosophy, this, plus his healthy arm, power stuff, and horse-like physique still gives him a decent shot as a very solid, "effectively wild", back-end or #3 level, inning-eating starter.