69 ABs in April, 65 in May before he went to the DL and 53 in June, so actually your comparison of month to month is somewhat faulty. And I would be the first to state that Plouffe is wildly erratic at the plate- which is why I pointed out his hot/cold history in 2013, which mirrors his past career performance, which also makes it highly problematic that he will be around for long, possibly moved in the offseason to avoid arbitration. Yes, Plouffe had an awful July, but consider these numbers for July: Plouffe: .189/.223/.300 Manny Machado: .196/.226/.314 (ranked #4 in WAR @ 3B) Evan Longoria: .194/.288/.347 (ranked #3 in WAR @ 3B) or August: Plouffe: .196/.264/.330 Kyle Seager: .194/.303/.340 (ranked #7 in WAR @ 3B) Todd Frazier: .180/.247/.337 (ranked #8 in WAR @ 3B) The above 4 counter-examples show that even the best in the game have disastrous months. Plouffe isn't one of the best in the game and close monitoring and intervention is necessary to both maximize his value and prevent him from hurting the team when he's clearly struggling. I suggested previously what a more creative team might do with him, accentuate what he is very good at (kills lefties/can possibly move into a super-utility role), and minimize and tweak in the areas where he has a history of struggling mightily- ie, tough RHPs and prolonged slumps being two of his major weaknesses (Danny Valencia has earned himself strong consideration for continuing his specialist role with the Orioles in 2014, what with his .1063 OPS against lefties this year, for his career, Valencia's slash against lefties is strikingly similar to Plouffe's, with a .517 SLG and .884 OPS, compared to Plouffe: .505 SLG and .856 OPS).