Second point first; the word "minutiae" probably doesn't apply here. Antony was wholly unfamiliar with the concept of batting average on balls in play, for heaven's sake, which has been a fundamental cornerstone of the effort to reduce random effects in player metrics for over a decade, as well as freely available even to the public by the time of that conversation. But that distinction is irrelevant if you believe Antony has since done his homework and is now either thoroughly educated on advanced metrics, or at least in possession of even just a working vocabulary, which he lacked previously. Two problems with that. One is that as recently as last spring, during his tenure as acting GM no less, he continued to discuss player valuations using only rudimentary counting stats and old, cigar-chomping scout phrases like 'the ball jumps off his bat'. With respect to Dozier in particular, he recited counting stats while discussing his contract extension late last year, choosing to ignore Dozier's somewhat paradoxical metrics, especially his worrisome sellout to an extreme pull fly ball tendency that is almost exclusively the domain of aging, one-tool power hitters. The second problem to me is that while I am totally on board with learning from mistakes, how on earth did Antony find himself that far behind his peers with respect to metrics in the first place? The common thread in the background of virtually all pro baseball GM's, coaches, and scouts is an absolute love of baseball that dates back to early childhood. Combine that with an almost universal thirst among executives in any field for 'insider information' about their trade, and a major league front office's constant drive to outsmart the competition, and it's almost impossible to imagine how an ambitious, hard-working front office exec could have such a large blind spot regarding even basic baseball metrics, unless he simply refused to allow that they are potentially of value. And that's not a guy you want running your franchise. An army of Jack Goins won't get through to a GM Rob Antony if he doesn't understand their language or believe their message.