He didn't hit for more power than Dozier. He hit a lot more singles than Dozier and had an .080 higher batting average. Dozier had 35 doubles, 5 triples, 42 home runs. Murphy had 47 doubles, 5 triples, 25 home runs, though he did it in roughly 100 less PAs. But Dozier had 17 more homers, which gives him the nod in the power department. Doubles are nice but homers plate runs. It'd be close but I'd probably take Dozier's 2016 over Murphy. I love Murphy's OBP but he's a butcher in the field... And remember that this discussion was about "best second baseman", not "best hitting second baseman". In the hitting department, an argument could be made for either player. Dozier has the homers, Murphy the doubles and OBP. But on the defensive side of the field, Murphy is vastly inferior to Dozier. And besides, my point was originally about Murphy's outlier 2016 as a reason he shouldn't be third on the list. Dozier has been better for longer than Murphy and a few of the players below Murphy on the list have been better than either Dozier or Murphy for a much longer period of time (Pedroia and Kinsler). It's basically indefensible to have Murphy third on that list. No stat backs up that assertion, either career or 2016.