Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    Young Guns


    Nick Nelson

    Over the six-year period from 2011 through 2016, during which the Twins won at a miserable .419 clip and finished last in the division four times, here's how many times a starting pitcher under the age of 27 threw 100-plus innings with a better than average ERA: one.

    Scott Diamond, in 2012, posted a fluky 3.54 ERA over 27 starts at age 25. He fizzled out after one more big-league season and is now pitching in Korea.

    Image courtesy of Jesse Johnson, USA Today

    Twins Video

    Minnesota rotations of the last half-decade have featured a couple of impressive veteran campaigns and few other positives. For an organization with such emphatic focus on acquiring and developing young arms to receive not one convincing standout season from a youthful starter over such a span is damning. It also tells you all you need to know about the club's perpetual run prevention problems.

    In this light, what we've seen from Jose Berrios and Adalberto Mejia over the past week has been borderline revelatory. It's important to not get carried away on the basis of three starts, but there's plenty of legitimate reason for encouragement.

    Obviously, Berrios has been nothing short of incredible in two starts since rejoining the team. He has gone 7.2 in both turns, and the only run scored against him came on a wild pitch. Opponents have not been able to muster anything against his blazing heater and bendy breaking balls. This is the player we expected based on Berrios' mastery of the minors and truly special pitch arsenal.

    He obviously won't sustain an ERA below one, and he may not ultimately pan out as a true No. 1 type, but Berrios is clearly becoming more comfortable and doesn't turn 23 for a few more days. After generating some doubt with a disastrous debut in 2016, the Puerto Rican righty is regaining his status as a rotation building block that the Twins sorely need.

    He may be joined by Mejia, who picked up his first big-league victory in the second half of Sunday's double-header with a strong effort against the Royals. The southpaw had a couple of pitches tail into the sweet spot of Salvador Perez's righty bat and leave the yard, but was otherwise exceptional, cruising through seven innings on 89 pitches while throwing 67 percent strikes.

    Mejia doesn't have the lofty ceiling of Berrios, but seems to have a pretty high floor, which might have factored into the Twins surprisingly handing him a rotation spot out of camp. The left-hander's erratic April audition in the rotation was quite uncharacteristic, and on Sunday he looked much more like the pitcher his numbers advertise. The guy with a 1.21 WHIP and 86-to-19 K/BB in 93 innings at Triple-A.

    If he's throwing his mid-90s fastball and mid-80s slider for strikes, and getting anything from his changeup, Mejia has a reliable formula for success. He executed the plan on Sunday, as he did in four starts for Rochester during his demotion. He turns 24 next month.

    Pitching is the currency of baseball – more specifically, young and controllable pitching. The Twins have been bankrupt in this area for entirely too long, leading to the destitute state that triggered a front office overhaul. But Berrios and Mejia are harbingers of a shifting tide, and on another note of optimism, Twins Daily's No. 2 prospect Stephen Gonsalves finally made his season debut at Chattanooga on Saturday, tossing four solid innings while easing back into action.

    Gonsalves missed the first six weeks rehabbing a sore shoulder, but all signs point toward him being back at full strength. If he picks up where he left off with the Lookouts last year (8-1 with a 1.82 ERA following a June promotion) he'll quickly be in the mix as an option for the Twins. Same goes for his Double-A rotation-mate and fellow 22-year-old Fernando Romero, who has been inconsistent but is most importantly healthy. He possesses the ability to get on a roll at any time, and is already on the 40-man roster.

    It's been a long time since the Twins have had such volume of available or tangibly close good young arms. And given the state of their rotation, the timing couldn't be better.

    Mejia's redemptive performance on Sunday followed a deflating one from Phil Hughes, who lasted only four innings while coughing up five runs on three homers. It was his third straight crummy start, and afterward the veteran landed on the disabled list with shoulder discomfort. He'd been throwing with the lowest velocity of his career and allowing loud contact at an extraordinary rate, so at this stage there's no evident beneficial impact from offseason shoulder surgery. In fact, Hughes spoke after the game of a "dead feeling" very similar to the symptoms that led to his thoracic outlet syndrome diagnosis. Quite troubling.

    Fortunately, the budding emergence of Berrios and Mejia enables the Twins to give Hughes a break without worrying too much. It also lessens the urgency of a successful return for Kyle Gibson on Monday night, though that would certainly help.

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Riley Quick

    Fort Myers Mighty Mussels - A, RHP
    Start #3 for the 21-year-old went well again. He tossed three scoreless innings with no walks. He gave up one hit and had three strikeouts. In 8 IP through 3 starts, he's given up 0 runs, 1 hit, 3 walks, and 13 strikeouts.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

     

    I wasn't saying there was no talent in the system. I understand how it can be perceived that way, but it wasn't my intent. The most likely outcome of the current system is that it will provide 0 star players, but will produce a number of solid MLB players. The current Twins team has a few guys who could turn into stars, a handful of guys who will be solid players for a number of years, and some old guys we shouldn't be counting on beyond a year or 2. The current pitching staff (starters and bullpen) have 1 guy who may be above average, a handful of guys who can be average (#3 starter, solid bullpen arm), and a whole bunch of junk. Trading away all of your depth in the minors for a single starter gives your pitching staff 2 possible above average starters, a handful of guys who can be (emphasis on can be) average, and a whole bunch of junk without any real depth coming from the minors. That doesn't help the 2017 Twins let alone the 2018-2022 Twins. And while we have good prospects and depth in the minors we don't have anyone that gets you a top ranked pitcher. As someone pointed out earlier it took a top 25 prospect to get a Drew Pomeranz last year. Piling a whole bunch of mid level prospects doesn't get you a #1 or 2 starter. Teams want big time prospects. That means it takes Gordon and Gonsalves to even start a conversation for a pitcher who may actually help.

     

    To me this all comes down to the fact that this Twins team is more of a mirage than a true competitor this year. And to me you just don't sacrifice anything of the future for a run during a year where you're not realistically going to win in the playoffs. Getting to the playoffs and getting swept, again, isn't something worth hoping for for me. I know it'd be nice to be there, but I'd prefer they run with the team they have. Win 78-83 games. Get the young guys a ton of at bats while mixing in the guys in the minors here and there to start seeing if they're going to be pieces of the team the next couple years. Draft Kyle Wright and let him advance quickly if he's showing he can. Get him some time in the ML pen at the end of the year and hope he's running 1,2,3 with Berrios and Mejia by June next year with Gonsalves joining by then as well and Romero and Stewart getting cups of coffee to fill in for injuries. Fix the bullpen this offseason and be ready to roll for years.

     

    I think much of this is a difference in approach between some of us. I want sustained success with realistic shots at the WS. I don't think trading for a single player this year accomplishes either of those things and actually sets the Twins back from being able to do either because it depletes their depth. I want them to complete this rebuild and then be able to trade both major leaguers and prospects to help maintain success. They're never going to be big players in free agency as the Pohlads just won't pay for that. But trading some major leaguers (probably Sano if we're being realistic) as the reach the end of arbitration to bring in big time prospects and also trading some prospects to help fill holes balances things out and lets them stay competitive. The team is just too far away right now to start making trades for individual players.

    Not to pick on you, but I've been reading some version of this post for several years now.  

     

    "Now's not the time.  Wait.  The minor leaguers are coming.  Don't trade.  Don't sign bullpen help.  Don't sign free agents.  In two years, we'll be good, and THEN go get the guys needed to be good."

     

    I will give you credit for being the first person to mention trading Sano, though.

     

    Uff-da.

     

     

     

     

    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-625632
    Share on other sites

     

    1.  legit starter:  better than what the Twins are running out at 4 and 5 right now.

    Duffey might be able to do that (and more), for free.  And we're 2 months away from trade season, so we've got time to find out.

     

    I'm having a hard time reconciling your position that Duffey has to stay in the pen, but the Twins should be aggressively trying to address the rotation in the short term.  Why not Duffey to the rotation, Burdi to the pen, and you can re-evaluate when teams start listening to trade offers in July?

     

    That seems like a way better use of resources, for both the short and long term, than spending prospect capital right away trying to get whatever starter a team is willing to deal early.

    Edited by spycake
    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-625633
    Share on other sites

    USAFChief, on 23 May 2017 - 11:22 AM, said:

    1.  legit starter:  better than what the Twins are running out at 4 and 5 right now. 

     

    2.  I pay very little attention to Fangraphs, even less to their projections, and even less than that to WAR, so I don't care about any of that.  The Twins are currently on pace for 90 wins.  We're a quarter of the way through the season.  That's reality, and with some help, I see no reason they can't come close to maintaining that pace.

     

     

     

    Well, there are AAAA pitchers that meet your criteria, so it is basically a meaningless standard.

     

    You can not care about projections all you want, but every front office considers how strong of a club they have before making major decisions. You're not considering the issue seriously if you don't. The Twins are 25% of the way through the season and 1 game up on Cleveland, a clearly superior team. Making ill-informed decisions based on gut feel is obviously not a path to success. 

     

    Just because so far as you can "see," the Twins are close to a 90-win caliber team, doesn't mean that objectively your gut feelings have any validity. 

     

     

    Sorry, it has to be said.  It's like a baseball conversation between Kirk and Spock.

     

    Ok, back to seriousness now.

    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-625637
    Share on other sites

     

    Not to pick on you, but I've been reading some version of this post for several years now.  

     

    "Now's not the time.  Wait.  The minor leaguers are coming.  Don't trade.  Don't sign bullpen help.  Don't sign free agents.  In two years, we'll be good, and THEN go get the guys needed to be good."

     

    I will give you credit for being the first person to mention trading Sano, though.

     

    Uff-da.

    I actually agree with any frustration you have towards the idea of not signing bullpen help or free agents. If by "not trading" you're referring to the guys we've had in the bigs over the last 6-7 years then I agree with you that we should have been open to that. If you're referring to trading prospects I don't understand what you thought that would have accomplished. Instead of losing 95+ they'd lose 90+ and have nobody in the system coming to help and nobody to trade for help and have to rely simply on free agents?

     

    I suggested they are going to have to trade Sano before he hits free agency. I don't think that's a crazy idea. Losing your best player for nothing is killer for a mid market team who's owners want to be run as a small market team. Obviously, there's conversations that will have to take place behind the scenes that we'll never know about and the first choice is to extend him a couple years past his arb years and to do it sooner than later, but I don't think it's going out on a limb to say Sano is going to want a big, fat paycheck down the road and the Twins are not likely to pay it.

    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-625646
    Share on other sites

    The Twins are not coming from a position of strength when it comes to trading away prospects. This is purely an academic conversation because if they did this they would be gutting themselves. As much as it sucks, TR left the Twins pretty thin and the organization needs to be acquiring prospects and not trading them, and they must explore free agency at the same time.

     

    Sure we heard this for a long time. The difference is under TR it was a BS excuse for not wanting to put in the effort to explore free agency or the trade market. Right now stocking the minors is a need, and the Twins can do both as any successful team does. The "we can only do one of these things successfully" was a dumb narrative that none of us should have ever accepted.

    Edited by Doomtints
    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-625667
    Share on other sites

     

    You had me until the Gordon reference. He's legit.

    Anyone else in the system could be traded (in the right deal) without too much worry.

    I figured that part might get some people, that's why I put the IMO in there!

    Fangraphs had him projected like this when we drafted him:
     

    Hit GamePower RawPower Speed Field Throws Future Value
    20 / 55 20 / 50 45 / 50 50 / 50+ 50 / 55 60 / 60 55

    Good, not necessarily a star.  He started 2 games at 2nd last year compared to 103 at SS.  This year he's started 14 at 2nd already with 26 at SS.  I haven't seen him play enough to say he can or can't stick at short, but I haven't heard many scouts say that he certainly will.  

    He's hitting well this year, offsetting a career high K% (21% not bad) with career high BB%.  His BABIP is 30 points higher despite moving up a level, while his slugging % is 100 points higher (3HR this year compared to 3 all of last year)  This is often the way a young prospects grow as hitters.  However, I'm still not sure he'll hit enough to be above average.  And if he can't stick at short, his value plummets. 

    If his last name were Nishioka instead of Gordon, would people be so high on him?  To me, he's an obvious candidate to be overvalued by outside organizations.
     

    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-626192
    Share on other sites

    I figured that part might get some people, that's why I put the IMO in there!

     

    Fangraphs had him projected like this when we drafted him:

     

    Hit GamePower RawPower Speed Field Throws Future Value

    20 / 55 20 / 50 45 / 50 50 / 50+ 50 / 55 60 / 60 55

     

    Good, not necessarily a star. He started 2 games at 2nd last year compared to 103 at SS. This year he's started 14 at 2nd already with 26 at SS. I haven't seen him play enough to say he can or can't stick at short, but I haven't heard many scouts say that he certainly will.

     

    He's hitting well this year, offsetting a career high K% (21% not bad) with career high BB%. His BABIP is 30 points higher despite moving up a level, while his slugging % is 100 points higher (3HR this year compared to 3 all of last year) This is often the way a young prospects grow as hitters. However, I'm still not sure he'll hit enough to be above average. And if he can't stick at short, his value plummets.

     

    If his last name were Nishioka instead of Gordon, would people be so high on him? To me, he's an obvious candidate to be overvalued by outside organizations.

     

    I think he is starting to exceed draft day projections/grades. He has performed enough that his last name no longer matters to me.

     

    He's not untouchable by any means, but it is now pretty clear to me that he has established enough to be clear what value the Twins are giving up, a future solid regular, probably at SS.

    Link to comment
    https://twinsdaily.com/forums/topic/26026-article-young-guns/#findComment-626213
    Share on other sites




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...