Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    One Step Backward


    Nick Nelson

    At one of his pregame lunchroom press scrums on a mid-March day in Fort Myers, Terry Ryan was asked about his level of concern with the young and inexperienced players who would figure prominently into the team's plans this year.

    "I worry about almost every guy that comes up here," the GM said. "They have instant success and things are looking good. Sometimes when guys come back it doesn't fall into place, it starts to unravel a bit. We send them back."

    Image courtesy of Jonathan Dyer, USA Today

    Twins Video

    Ryan obviously has a lot of faith in his youthful core, and with good reason. But he's been doing this long enough to recognize that things don't always play out according to plan.

    "Every guy that's come through here with the exception of maybe a handful in the last 20 years has had to go back. Mauer didn't go back. Knoblauch didn't go back. Those types of guys."

    Of course, we'd all like to believe that transcendent talents like Byron Buxton and Miguel Sano are "those types of guys," but Ryan pointed to a number of players who needed to be sent back to the minors after their initial call-up – sometimes multiple times – before going on to have long and successful big-league careers. Included on that list are names like Torii Hunter, Corey Koskie and LaTroy Hawkins. A.J. Pierzynski shuttled back and forth between the minors and majors repeatedly back in the late '90s, and he's still playing today.

    So as we watch Buxton, Eddie Rosario, and even Byung Ho Park scuffle along, it's important to keep in mind that a step backward is sometimes required before taking two steps forward. I have a hard time envisioning a demotion for Sano but with the other three it's quickly going to become a consideration as the uncompetitive at-bats pile up.

    On a larger scale, it's looking like the Twins, as a team, will need to take a step backward before they can move forward. They've dug themselves a deep hole at the start of the season and being forced to send down one or more of their key young players, while replacing them with mediocrities like David Murphy, would almost surely peg this year as a developmental one aimed toward getting everything in place for a 2017 run.

    Perhaps that was always the most realistic outcome given the level of inexperience on the roster, but one can hardly be blamed for being impatient after a five-year playoff drought, or for feeling optimistic in light of the elite abilities of these admittedly green youngsters.

    Unfortunately, it looks like they're just not there yet, and neither are the Twins.

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Khadim Diaw

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, C/OF
    In the first three games of the Kernels' series in Lansing, Diaw has gone 7-for-13 with two doubles, two homers, four runs, four RBI. Now hitting .295/.404/.440 15 doubles, a triple, and four home runs.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    Whether you send a send a young guy down who is struggling, has more to do about his mindset, than his physical ability. If you got this far, you must have shown the ability to hit some pretty good pitching. How you mentally handle the inevitable learning curve at this next level should determine if you need or don't need more time in AAA. One thing is certain, you cannot learn to hit MLB pitching, in the minors!

    I can live with multiple young guys having slow starts, and this turning out to be a developmental year. A bummer, but the future is still bright. Whether Rosario, Buxton, Sano, and Park work out their problems up here or down in the minors doesn't really matter, ultimately, as long as they do eventually. What would bother me would be if they gave the resulting at bats to Murphy instead of Arcia. If he's on the team, and there's a lineup opening, he should be playing, not some veteran stop gap. If they know they don't want him they should have cut him. If they think he has enough potential not to give up on, they should be playing him whenever they can. I have nothing against Murphy but there is no way he is part of the long term solution. If the playoffs are not in the picture, and they are just developing young guys, that should include people like Arcia and Vargas, too, not stop gap veterans. I have no problem with signing Murphy -- at this point, their entire outfield and starting DH are question marks -- as long as he's last in line after anyone with a future here.

     

    Whether you send a send a young guy down who is struggling, has more to do about his mindset, than his physical ability. If you got this far, you must have shown the ability to hit some pretty good pitching. How you mentally handle the inevitable learning curve at this next level should determine if you need or don't need more time in AAA. One thing is certain, you cannot learn to hit MLB pitching, in the minors!

     

    This is a component, but hardly the only thing.  Some guys just aren't ready and need to work on some things, and you don't want them working on said things at the major league level where they are dragging down the roster. 




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...