Baseball America's Top 50 Dynasty Catchers

[Seth Stohs]

I enjoy lists like this, especially for those who play fantasy baseball. I am in one keeper league with a 29-man roster and a 30-man minor league roster. Definitely interesting. Dynasty is a keeper league in which once you have a player on your roster, you have that player until you make the decision to let them go. You could draft Justin Verlander and have him for 1 or 2 years, or you could draft Jackson Chourio and have him on your roster for the next 20 years. 

With that background, Baseball America is in the middle of a series in which they have been ranking the top 50 players by position in terms of their value in a dynasty league today... (please click on the link for much more... but discuss here). 

Here are Twins, AL Central players, and whoever is #1... I'll split these up by position so that we can get into more depth on the individuals. 

Catchers: 
#1: Adley Rutschman, Orioles 
#8: Bo Naylor, Guardians 
#19: Salvador Perez, Royals
#20: MJ Melendez, Royals
#23: Mitch Garver, Mariners
#25: Ryan Jeffers, Twins 
#36: Edgar Quero, White Sox 
#46: Dillon Dingler, Tigers 
#47: Jair Camargo, Twins 

Personal Opinion... Ryan Jeffers is way too low... With his relative youth (26) and the production he had offensively in 2023, I think he could be up another 10 spots. Fun to see Camargo here. No Christian Vazquez, obviously. 

What do you think?