So, if Kepler is a no go for the ALDS (a possibility that certainly can’t be ignored), how does that change things? I still think 12 pitchers is a must with Pineda out and Gibson and Perez ineffective to the point that both may not make the playoff roster. I still go with these starters, in this order: Odorizzi Dobnak Berrios Smeltzer Although, I might be inclined to start someone else (maybe Graterol or Littell or May) in game 4 and bring in Smeltzer to start the second inning. Not that I expect more than 2-3 out of Smeltzer anyway. Smeltzer would be available in the pen for game one and Dobnak in game 5. Relievers are Rogers Duffey Romo May Littell Stashak Graterol Perez Position players Castro Garver Astudillo Cron Arraez Schoop Sano Polanco Cruz Rosario Cave Gonzalez Miller Of course, there is no real back up shortstop. Could go with Torreyes over Miller but I don’t think I would as that would leave the team without a legitimate CFer. I think keeping Torreyes in the dugout to be activated in case of injury should suffice. Without Kepler, I think they absolutely need Miller. IMO, it’s a toss up between Wade and Cave for the starting CF job. I give the nod to Cave based on having more experience and also his power might play well in Yankee Stadium. Lineup vs RHP 2b Arraez ss Polanco dh Cruz rf Rosario 3b Sano c Garver lf Gonzalez 1b Astudillo cf Cave vs LHP c Garver ss Polanco dh Cruz 3b Sano rf Rosario 1b Cron 2b Schoop lf Gonzalez cf Cave