Well, I want to know ASAP if he can do this or not. I'll take the random brain farts that comes with juggling a ton of information if it means we're going to have a better read on the QB situation come Week 18.
The arm is there, and surprisingly to me, the decisiveness is way better than we saw the first two weeks. The biggest issue is the accuracy, which I didn't think was supposed to be a huge problem. I think it needs to quickly be determined if that's who McCarthy is, or if that's plausibly fixed.
Unpopular take here, but my expectations for this season are low, so I'm in the camp of giving him as much as he can handle if only to see if the accuracy and the decision making improve with more and more reps. If this team goes 4-13 because they threw it 40 times a game, but they can make a confident decision about McCarthy, I'll be happier than if they go 8-9 throwing it 20 times per game and still not having a clue.