I'm not sure I buy that. What about this year, Nate McClouth has 24SB compared to 4CS. Are the 4CS killing the positive value of his 24SB? Revere last year would be a prime example I suppose, as he stole 40 and had 9CS with a .675OPS in ~550PA. Extrapolate his numbers for a full year of ~650PA and I bet he easily has 50SB with roughly 12CS. It's practically impossible to actually account for the steals and caught stealing in the math, I get that, and it really is too bad. Further evidence of this - what about people like Span that get picked off at a high rate? EDIT: Actually, Everth Cabrera's year last year - .648OPS in 449PA. 44SB to 4CS. That might be a better example then Revere.