gagu

It's not that complicated, nor is it that simple. Your argument isn't realistic, IMO. Again, I'm not saying the theory is good or bad, just giving the person who originally asked about it an example of how a team worked the system to their advantage. Granted, the amounts allotted have changed, but there is some reasoning behind the strategy. I don't have a clue whether the gambit will work, but unless the team felt that Greene was the real thing, this draft didn't offer anyone worth latching onto for better or worse. Time will tell.

Hope is the word I used. I understand the comment, but suggesting that Falvey doesn´t have a plan seems to be jumping the gun a bit. The sup picks haven´t even been made yet. The repetitive boilerplate "Twins FO will blow it" comments are wearing on me. The Falvey regime has hardly started.

2012 draft. Astros cut a lower deal with Correa at 1.1 and had the extra $$ to get McCullers to pass on his commitment to Florida. Right or wrong, it looks like the Twins are hoping lightning strikes twice. http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1205703-top-mlb-draft-prospect-lance-mccullers-prepared-to-bring-the-high-heat

This makes the rest of the night much more exciting. Can´t wait for the supp pick. Wow! A real roll of the dice here.

The Cardinals have been pretty successful with bringing future starters and using them in the bullpen. The injury history listed doesn't entirely correlate with that process, imo. Wainwright broke in as a 23-year-old with two short relief outings, a total of nine batters faced. He came out the bullpen 61 times the following year, then became a front-line starter the last 9+ seasons, with at least 198 innings pitched in seven of them. He only had 20 starts in '08 and suffered his severe injury in '15. his age 33 season. This after pitching a total of 568 combined innings the previous two years. Garcia broke in at age 21, with 1 start in 10 appearances to go with 106 innings in the minors. To support your point, he only made 8 starts (9 appearances) the following season. He made 60 starts over the next two seasons and then battled injuries in each of the next three seasons. He had 30 starts last season and 10 so for this year. Wacha arrived in 2013 after 15 ML starts. He made 9 regular season starts in 15 total appearances and 64.2 innings worked. He then racked up another 30.2 innings in the post-season, going 4-1 and was the MVP of the NLCS. Like Garcia, Wacha was injured the following season, with 19 total starts.30 starts in '15; 24 starts last season and 3 games in relief. ) starts this year. As a 22-year-old, Rosenthal arrived in '12 after 20 minor league starts and 109 innings. He pitched 22 innings out of the pen in the regular season followed by three scoreless innings in the post-season. As a major leaguer, Rosenthal pitched exclusively out of the pen. In his 6th season, he has a 162 game average of 68 appearances, 68 innings, and 25 saves.His injury came last season, holding him to only 40 games, but he is right back to form this season. Also, Carlos Martinez broke in at age 21 as a spot starter for two years after being a minor league starter. He has transitioned into an ace starter with no injury issues. Alex Reyes was 4-1 last year, with a 1.57 ERA in five MLB starts and seven relief appearances at age 21 plus 65 innings pitched in Memphis.He had 73 minor league appearances, all of them starts. He's a TJ patient. He was the #2 rated prospect in the MLB. Marco Gonzales was scheduled to pitch in the Futures Game in '14 at age 22 but was scratched when he was called up to fill in for an injured Jaime Garcia-. He ended the regular season with 10 games, 5 starts, 34 innings, and a 4.15 ERA. Like the others, he pitched in the postseason that year. He battled a shoulder injury the following year but did get a September call-up. He then missed last season with TJ surgery. He was the Cards 5th rated prospect. Shelby Miller and Joe Kelly are the only other examples I can think of. They both were minor league starters that come up as spot starters, Shelby at age 21, Kelly at 24. And like Wacha, Martinez, and Lynn, they too went on to pitch in the post-season in the first year they were called up. Miller has gone on to average 33 starts a year. Kelly started 15 of 37 appearances in his second season, then became a full-time starter for two seasons and 42 total starts. Chris Carpenter missed nearly all of his final season in '12 after leading the league in innings pitched in ´11, but he was 37 years old and had already worked back from four previous injuries in his long career. He ended up having a rib removed and returned to pitch 13,2 post-season innings, giving up 4 earned runs. Conclusion: mixed bag, but a successfully mixed bag. The Cards have always managed to develop outstanding young pitchers to augment a consistently strong starting rotation. I don't think any other franchise can match them. Because they are so often in the post-season, they have an extra incentive to use their outstanding starting pitcher prospects in the bullpen to start their careers. That isn't the case in Minnesota at this time. So after throwing all these stats out, I'm not convinced one way or the other. I´m a true blue loyal Twins fan, but I take some solace in following the Cards in the NL. It´s much less painfull.

So many assumptions and/or exaggerations. I guess the deal now is that the Yanks "dumped" Murphy, while the Twins sacrificed Hicks!?!? Two teams trade players at positions with depth for players at positions of need. Not particularly surprising, an extended thread I read last night on another site included a majority of Yankee fans, who stated a definate opinion, ripping the trade and damning Cashman. Some things are universal.

TWINS GET: P Kevin Jepsen RAYS GET: P Chih-Wei Hu Charlotte Class Adv A, 0-3 W-L, 18 inn, 7.36 ERQ P Alexis Tapia Princeton Class A, 1-0 W-L, 23.1 Inn, 3.86 ERA

I love these articles and appreciate the information. One request for the future: please consider adding the position and age of the players listed, especially at the lower levels. It may not be relevant to a particular story, but it's a good habit and it adds the reading experience. Not a criticism, I'm more than happy with the year-round coverage and insightful comments. Thanks.

"-to-trade-or-not-to-trade-plouffe-this-offseason" Unless I missed something, no one is talking about trading him this month.

I think that was his point.

Just have to compliment you on this very solid, thorough analysis.