The problem people had with Punto was how he was utilized by Gardy and some of the things Gardy said about him. Gardy saying things like: -Punto is the best defender we have at whatever position he's at. -The #1 offseason priority for this team should be to re-sign Punto to be the starting shortstop. -If everyone else on the team was doing their job, no one would talk about Punto's inability to hit. Things like that, and that's only the tip of the iceberg. To me, the disdain Punto got was completely unfair to Punto (though I admit, I am embarrassed to say there were times I was there too) Truth is, all Punto ever did for us was give 100% all the time. What was he going to do, tell Gardy he won't play when Gardy keeps putting him in the lineup? Also, Punto never had a negative fWAR with the Twins.