To me, whoever the 'powers that be' figure are the best five that's the five that should be in the rotation. I'm not married to my list, it's just who I would go with. I'm not claiming my list is 100% correct. We all have different ways we evaluate pitchers. If someone else, like you, has a different best five and the 'powers that be' agree, let's go with that five. Doesn't matter to me. The whole point was, whichever five are the best should be in the rotation instead of giving starts to the sixth best, whomever that may be. This is, of course, if the goal is to try and wins as many games as possible this year. I honestly don't see us making the playoffs, so maybe our course of action should be guided by different goals.