Bingo! Something about him just strikes me as phony. The numerous variations of face paint and the Mr. Twins Community image he tries to portray are examples. Like when Pete Rose would sprint to 1B after a walk or dive headfirst into a bag when the ball was nowhere near, to support his image as Charlie Hustle, Lewis seems very conscious of an image he wants to create. Phil Mickelson was very popular with fans but wasn't well liked by other players who saw his public image as phony.
But, I could overlook all this if he would just perform on the field, which he doesn't.