I've never said FAs don't work out sometimes, people asked, on this thread, what I would do to make the team competitive sooner rather than later. I suggested signing one "decline phase" FA in my plan, 1. I think that guy will not fall off the face of the earth in the next 3-4 years (yes, he might at the end of the deal, but that is the chance you take if you ever want to sign a FA) and 1 expensive guy in his prime. We can disagree on our prediction of whether or not Ellsbury will decline too fast, but to state it like fact is no better than what you are accusing me of doing. As for no one saying they can't be competitive next year, there are several posts in this thread saying that exactly. I disagree, and it is ok to disagree. The OP asked for suggestions on how to be better next year, I gave them. Feel free to disagree.