mikelink45

It was a good choice - Versalles really electrified the game for those of us who were watching in 1965, but Oliva would have been a good choice too and overall was the better player, just not in 1965. ESPN had an article on "one hit wonders" for each team. They chose Versalles for the Twins. It is a choice I disagree with, but this is what they said, "In the National League list of one-hit wonders, I wrote about Jim Konstanty, the 33-year-old relief pitcher for the Phillies who won the MVP award in 1950. Versalles is in some fashion the American League version of Konstanty, probably the least accomplished player to win an AL MVP. While he had a fairly long MLB career, including seven seasons as a regular, Versalles finished with just 12.6 career WAR, and the only season he topped 3.0 was in 1965. While he finished with just a .319 OBP, the lowest ever for a non-pitcher MVP, Versalles did a lot of other things that season: He led the AL in runs (126), doubles (42), triples (12), extra-base hits (76) and total bases (308) while also winning a Gold Glove. He stole 27 bases in 32 attempts. The Twins won the pennant and, in a weak season for star performances, Versalles led all position players in WAR (only Cleveland pitcher Sam McDowell was higher). It's hard to picture a guy with a .319 OBP being the best player in the league, but Versalles was a worthy selection and received 19 of the 20 first-place votes. Versalles was only 25 that season, but never came close to replicating that performance. In 1966, he battled a severe case of the flu into May and got off to a slow start, then injured his heel, which led to a painful hematoma in his back (blood leakage and tissue swelling). He would suffer recurring back pain the rest of his career, and his power numbers nosedived. It didn't help that he had always been error-prone at shortstop (he made 39 errors in 1965). He would spend his post-baseball years in the Minneapolis area, unemployed much of the time and subsisting on disability and Social Security checks and a small baseball pension. He was forced to sell his MVP trophy and was found dead from heart disease in his home in 1995, just 55 years old." It is true he did not replicate that season, but he did not fall off the map like a Bob Hazle with the Milwaukee team. We have our share of players who came up and looked great only to fade the next year.

Take Chacin out of the discussion and I agree completely with your well written essay. Thanks for the reflection. But give me Dobnak, Thorpe, Balazovic, Duran and let Chacin move on.

It is really hard to compare eras. In the past only a few - Feller, Ryan, Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove, Christy Mathewson...were potential triple digit guys and now - we are seeing all kinds of relief and starters, minor and major leaguers hitting triples. Why? Training, techniques, good food. It was not bad to control the batter with other techniques - see Spahn and Maddox for great pitchers who were not overly aggressive on strike outs. In the past players wanted to hit 300 and they hated to strikeout. So many things change. But pitchers who come up and have a short period of success is something that has been common throughout baseball history.

That sounds great - let us know if any Twins besides Boof appear. Thanks for the information.

So glad you could enjoy and find new information! Baseball is so fun.

I think that the way this season is playing out is to the disadvantage of Cruz. As we look ahead he is not only facing age, but uncertainty. Staying sharp, being ready is a challenge to everyone, 39 year old bodies have less flexibility.

I just went through the roster of everyone who ever played for the Senators/Twins franchise. Only with Coronavirus would I do that. Well it was kind of fun and I put together a 26 man roster of the best names - from my perspective. These were last names only and it was hard to ignore the nicknames. Vic Power led off at first for the Twins since Power is our calling card and Early Wynn (perfect names) is our starting pitcher. Some are a little more obscure - actually I never heard of many of them. But here it is. Have at it - add and subtract as you like. 1B Vic Power 2B Jimmy Bloodworth 3B Rocky Bridges SS Sam Crane C Earl Battey OF Steve Braun OF Eric Bullock OF Goose Goslin P Early Wynn P Red Bird P Boof Bonser P John Butcher P Matt Capps P Jim Constable P Skipper Friday P Eric Hacker P Jim Hoey P Jim Kaat P Joe Klink P Spencer Pumpelly Bench B Brian Dinkelman – 2B B Jake Early – C B Butch Huskey – OF B Clyde Kluttz – C B Elmer Klumpp – C B Bob Unglaub - U I also played with individual letters. This meant letters with a lot of names like "S". The weakness in this is apparent right away - the players were not Senator/Twins for their entire career so their numbers are inflated. For my exercise it is as if they were potentially on our teams their entire career and if they were this is how they stacked up. 1B George Sisler HOF 56.4 2b Germany Schaefer 8.9 3b Miquel Sano 7.8 Ss Roy Smalley 27.9 C Terry Steinbach 28 Of Tris Speaker HOF 134.2 Of Al Simmons HOF 68 Of Roy Sievers 25.5 P Jack Sandford 18.6 P Johann Santana 51.7 P Ervin Santana 26.6 P Bill Singer 18.7 p Lee Stange 9.2 464.5 total WAR The R team does not have a total WAR because you will see that the list does not have enough potential to be beat the S team. 1B Rich Rollins 2b Luis Rivas 3b Rich Reese Ss Pete Runnels C Phil Roof Of Ben Revere Of Sam Rice HOF Of Eddie Rosario P Brad Radtke P Pedro Ramos P Jeff Reardon P Kenny Rogers p Dutch Reuther The P team had 302.9 WAR but lacked the total star power. 1B Vic Power 15.3 2b Trevor Plouffe 7.2 3b Mike Pagliarulo 10.6 Ss Roger Peckinpaugh 44.9 C A J Pierzynski 23.8 Of Wally Post 18.2 Of Kirby Puckett 51.1 Of Albie Pearson 13.1 P Jim Perry 41.6 P Camilo Pascual 40.9 P Carl Pavano 16.4 P Mike Pineda 10.9 p Glen Perkins 8.9 302.9 The M's make a big push with 378.8 WAR 1B Justin Morneau 27 2b Buddy Myer 47.8 3b David McKay 0.1 Ss Pat Meares 4.8 C Joe Mauer 55.3 Of Paul Molitor HOF 75.7 Of Heinie Manush HOF 47.2 Of Shane Mack 21.6 P Firpo Marberry 30.3 P Tippy Martinez 8.6 P Joe Mays 9.4 P Eric Milton 16.5 p Jack Morris HOF 43.5 378.8 1B Ron Coomer 1.4 2b Rod Carew HOF 81.3 3b John Castino 15.2 Ss Joe Cronin 64.1 C Juan Castro -5.4 Of Ben Chapman 41.9 Of Marty Cordova 7.7 Of Michael Cuddyer 17.8 P Steve Carlton HOF 90.2 P Stan Coveleski HOF 61.4 P Dean Chance 29.9 P Al Cicotte 0.3 p Bartolo Colon 45.8 451.6 comes in second thanks to the HOF players Those were the letters I chose. K has Killebrew and Kaat, but not enough supporting cast. B has a lot of players but only Blyleven is HOF. D has only Ed Delehanty. W does not have as many players, but Walter Johnson has 164 WAR by himself. I cannot continue - my boredom has been replaced by being tired.

I can see this is not going to be a guy that we look forward to having interviews with. Of course all I really want is to see him on the mound.

I'm all for tovar. He just did so many things on the field, on the bench, with his attitude. He was a spark that ignited the great twins teams of the '60s. I'm not sure war is the measure for the question you've asked. I would even venture to say that Nick Punto might belong in this discussion. Radtke during his time gained accolades. Maybe Dave Goltz belongs in the pitcher discussion.

I have never discounted RBIs and I have not like the modern way of saying they don't matter. They do and this is a great article the demonstrates that they do. Way to go Rosario. Despite the naysayers your stats show how valuable you were

Oh my - Vic Power was the best. I loved to watch him play. https://alchetron.com/Vic-Power-(baseball) No one owned the base like he did. He was criticized for his flashy moves and unorthodox style (and it was style) but he was named the 81st greatest first baseman in Major League history by historian Bill James and that is underrated. He was flash, he was fun, and he was very good. He had seven gold gloves in 12 seasons. Three seasons he was in the top ten in fewest errors. Six seasons he had the most assists for a first baseman and 8 seasons he was in the top ten. Two seasons he was judges to have the top range for a 1B and 8 seasons he was in the top ten. He is ninth overall in total zone runs at 1st Base. He is my number one!

It looks like you're having fun. I used to play aPBA and really enjoyed it even though it was far from realistic.

This is a very thoughtful and interesting post. It really does take a different strategy and approach depending on the length of the season. Part of the issue will be if they try to crowd the games into a short span without the normal off days for travel that are part of the 162 game season. Many of the things that we want to see are only going to be answered when we finally see the season plan unfolded. As a person who is seen his work disappear I can tell you that my planning for the year changes weekly and all I can do is try to anticipate what might happen. The same will be true for the twins. but it appears as if they have a very thoughtful and coordinated front office through field management and that is the best thing we can ask for.

I wish I knew Thorpe's reasons for skipping what could have been his most important ST of his career. Without that knowledge the ability to look at him and where he is going is too limited.

We have to realize that pandemics like this usually reduce in the summer and then come back in the fall, often worse. The planning has to take this into consideration too.

Bob Allison is the best comp I can come up with in Twins history - eye test, not stats.

Pleasantly surprised - when the pitcher was good the previous regime did move them quickly. If only there had been more good ones.