The hardest part is there is no precedent for guys like Buxton coming back and being close to his ceiling. Corey Seager is the only player I can think of that had as high of an initial ceiling as Buxton, got hurt, and came back to be the player people thought he could be. The problem is, Seager wasn't consistently hurt like Buxton, so Buxton is in uncharted waters. Could he comeback and be good? Yeah sure. Will he? 85% no. If he comes back and plays 120 games in CF and has a 135 WRC+ for 3-4 years, I'll eat a shoe on Facebook live. He's done and will never live up to his hype.