Yeah. And it is because there are apples and oranges and people (like what you are doing up there) try to compare them. Big big picture: There are a couple types of "stats": Rate stats (things that usually divide by something - think PAs, IP etc) like BA, OBP, ERA, WHIP and cumulative stats (things that add, like RBIs, R, K, etc.). Batting average (like mph in your car) is a rate stat. WAR (like total miles in a trip or what the odometer of your car shows) is a cumulative stat. They both have their uses but you cannot compare them against each other. WAR is awesome for figuring things like belonging into the hall of fame after a long career but sucks for week to week comparisons. It is all about context and appropriate use. (and doing a bit of homework...)