You expressed my intent exactly. We can be supportive of the victim of someone's actions while in the throws of their addiction (or when not properly addressing other mental health concerns) while also having empathy and concern that the best be done individually for the person. I worked in a mental health delivery model that worked with those with extreme SPMI that were one step away from losing the ability to live independently. Those persons were seen often 3-5 times daily to assist with all things to do with their daily living activities. Many remain at that level of assistance for decades and never move to a less-intensive level of staff intervention due to the expedience of mania onset or psychiatric downslope when a person's chemical balance is out of sync. I've lived both sides of the issue, working with someone who was the kindest, most gentle person you could ever meet until his meds were off, but then he was willing to physically challenge me, a 6'3" former Gopher offensive lineman, leaving many incredibly frightened and at times leaving holes in walls or destruction on others' vehicles in his wake. He felt sincere remorse when no longer in the moment of a psychiatric "break" (I hate that word, but it's what is best understood for descriptive purposes) and would do all he could to repay financially any damage he'd done and apologize sincerely for his behaviors. Still, I'd hear often in public from those who didn't realize I worked with him that he should be locked up and the key thrown away. To address Hamilton, he has been surrounded in many cases with significant support, though what is reported as significant support and truly significant support for a person with dual diagnosis are two very different things. Regardless, what has been provided has obviously not been the right mix yet for Josh. Sadly, in the world of addiction, and especially in dual diagnosis, there is no blanket treatment, and each person will react individually, requiring a different mix of talk therapy, medication, social therapy (i.e. AA), exercise, diet, and so many other factors that play into finally finding what works...and even then, that could work for a season in life, not forever. One can support Josh not having contact with his daughter, think the actions are repulsive, and hope that his children and former spouse are getting the help they need while also at the same time avoiding quick assumptions that this is simply Josh's persona and not a sign of the need for a change in his present management system for his dual diagnosis.