Actually, Buster was correct, his ERA for 2012-13 was, in fact, 4.76. Major League Leaderboards » 2013 » Starters » Dashboard | FanGraphs Baseball But, in addition to maintaining his high K/9, throwing a No-No, and his xFIP being 3.68- his SIERA was 3.86. He's a better bounce-back candidate than Dan Haren (2-year FIP 4.18, xFIP 3.85, SIERA 3.85), still throwing 200 innings with a rubber arm (148 pitches thrown in his No-Hitter). Lincecum probably deserves the money, not really that much of a head-scratcher at all.