Barring crippling, Mickey Mantle-like ongoing injury issues, I think you and Thrylos are wildly underestimating Buxton's potential ceiling. On the defensive side, and perhaps it's a semantical misunderstanding, but Buxton's ceiling is not as "a plus defender", in point of fact, he's the epitome of a potential "plus-plus" CFer, and quite possibly could become the best defensive CFer in the majors over the first 10 years of his major league career. Offensively, I also don't get the discounting of the extraordinary season at the plate that Buxton accomplished in 2013. In the FSL, a league for which Buxton was nearly 4 years younger than the average age, he was the only 19 year old player in the FSL with 250+ PAs (in addition, there were only Five 20 Year Olds with 250+ PAs). To further put Buck's performance into perspective, if you scan the hitting lists over the last 5 years, it's hard to find ANY 19 Year Olds in the league with 250+ PAs, let alone in the Top Three in multiple major hitting categories. And don't get me wrong, I love Polanco, but here's the side-by-side comparison of his slash, one year older- at the age of 20, in the same league in 2014: Buxton- .326/.415/.472/.887 wOBA .406 wRC+ 155 (Top 3 in the FSL in every single category except SLG) Polanco- .291/.364/.415/.780 wOBA .359 wRC+ 124 And Polanco will likely not be even a "plus" defender, let alone Buxton's potential to be the best at his position in the game. Assuming that 2014 was a wild, health-related one-off for Buck, there's no reason to think he can't resume where he left off in 2013, and quickly move to claim the wide-open CF spot, possibly as early as July, but likely no later than sometime in the first half of 2016.