Bill Smith was not fired for having a losing team. He was fired over payroll issues. If they'd had the same losing season with a $100 million payroll, I think he'd still be GM (or at least would have been GM in 2012). Smith pushed Pohlad to the $115 million figure. But the 2011 season was a disaster (the first one the Twins had in years) and there was a public outcry for Smith's termination. In addition, I think season ticket sales were languishing. So, appease the public by firing Smith and better yet, bring back Terry Ryan who loves low payrolls and cut payroll not only for 2012 but added cuts in 2013. It all had to do with money. I'm not convinced that they won't renew Gardenhire's contract. I think part of it depends on what develops in the media over the rest of the summer and where they think season ticket sales will head if he is retained (or where they will head if he isn't retained). Last summer there seemed to be fairly heavy public support for keeping Gardenhire on as manager. I think that support is dwindling. If the powers-that-be perceive that keeping him on will hurt season ticket sales, he'll be persuaded to take another position with the club (unless he resigns on his own and he seems pretty stubborn about that). If they think season ticket holders mostly want Gardenhire to stay on as manager, they'll give him another 1 year contract. Always, always, it comes down to money with this club.