Saunders has had a weird season so far with some good games some terrible, and I'm not ready to give up on him being an asset, but his overall numbers aren't good at all in this table - I'm sure other pitchers can say the same about their one good start. Gunnarthor, an additional bit of info that would be useful in your table, some work for you one time but not needing updates, is the contact (years, dollars) each pitcher eventually signed for. I was in favor of giving Lannan a try, not because the odds of him turning out well were as high as for the others but because the cost of signing him would be nearly trivial. (I.e. no point in hoping for a deal that doesn't exist in Ryan's universe.)