Isn't the HOF ballot based off the players best 10 year stretch? If you include Joe's first 9 years as catcher - that alone is enough Last year (2017) hitting .305 and playing gold glove defense with a 3.4 WAR- as his 10th year. I feel like this alone adds up to his HOF resume. Some more stats that some may find interesting: Mauer ranks 5th all time as a 1B in Fielding Percentage Statistic Description: Fielding Percentage (Putouts + Assists) / (Putouts + Assists + Error He ranks 5th behind Casey Kotchman, Kevin Youkillis, Travis Lee, and Mark Texeira. He is just ahead of Doug Mientkewicz (who we all agree was great defensively at 1B at # 6) Goldschmidt, Helton, Smoak and Morneau at #10. Not bad for a position move due to career changing concussions that hit toward the peak of his career. HOF Voting: Voting shall be based upon the player's record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played. I would say that Joe was playing the majority of his career and excelling during the steroid error- all while being one of the best players in spite of the competition juicing. Joe is as clean a player as they come both on and off the field. This shouldn't be discounted.