I don't see the Twins signing one of the top 3 FA SP this year and I prefer they don't sign a FA SP (barring a trade of a current SP), unless it is a 1 year make good contract. Overall, I think they need to determine what they may have in May, Meyer, and Malone. I also think that, at this point, next years crop of FA SP is more appealing. Compare these lists of what are arguably the best likely available SP this year and next: Lester Scherzer Shields Burnett Kuroda Liriano Masterson McCarthy Peavy Santana Price Samardzija Zimmermann Cueto Kennedy Latos Buehrle Chen Fister Gallardo Iwakuma Kazmir Leake Lohse Norris Porcello You could argue about which class has the best top 3, but i think it's clear that next year has a deeper class of more desirable arms. The other reason to roll with what you have now is that there may well be a number of available arms at the trade deadline if you are in the race and want to upgrade at that time.