I think it is not as cut and dry as you think. Buxton is in low A, and Gausmann is going to start in MLB games this year. He's also looking better than people thought he'd look. Yes, Buxton is exciting and we can all hope he continues to be great at upper levels and here, but I don't think it is that cut and dry. Actually, I'd rather have Gausmann right now. He's more certain, and his ceiling is one of the top 20-30 pitchers in the game. Given that you need 5 starters, and they literally have zero right now, I'd still rather have Gausmann.