I suppose it depends on who "the others who understand" are... My guess is that not one poster on here will have been right about every move for the whole year. My own GMing would show me to be wrong about Hicks, Santana, Arcia, and Pelfrey, but right about Milone, Hughes, Gibson, and Hunter. Everyone will have some things to brag about, and to complain about. If anyone wants to criticize the Twins for apparently not "maximizing" the talent, they should also laud the Twins for having the options available which has allowed them to be wrong about Stauffer, Tonkin, Nolasco and Arcia and still be 10 over .500. Whether or not we're wrong about May, at present, we have the depth to be wrong, which is a good thing. As for May, I did look into May's solid xFIP and FIP. His FIP is brought down by a probably unsustainable top 15 in baseball HR/FB. His xFIP which uses league avg. for HR/FB is held down by his probably unsustainable 1.9 BB/9ip. I would guess that his FIP with his career avg. walks would be pretty darn close to his current ERA. IF his walk and HR rates aren't sustainable, then the Twins probably made the right move and maybe saved us a couple of those games come the end of the year!