There is more to it than a stupid decision by Toronto’s manager. That really has nothing to with Baldelli.
There is more to it than Lopez and Gray’s starts in this series.
There is no “myth.” Who is complaining about it right now? We have seen Baldelli pull pitchers at questionable times. He’s not made those types of decisions lately, that I can recall.
Not sure what the article is driving at. That Baldelli has never made any questionable calls? That people have issues with decisions he’s previously made were wrong? That everyone else is doing it, so it’s OK?
I think we just saw what can happen when a manager overanalyzes. I think we saw Baldelli do that that multiple times in the series with pinch hits. It just happened that the decisions didn’t come back into question because of a loss. But, I would’ve questioned if, for example, we lost a game or the series because Willy Castro struck out and grounded into a double play with the bases juiced in late inning situations, when it could have been Matt Wallner at the plate. Or, if Jax blew the game to Guerrero or Bichette in the 8th where he could’ve used Duran. Or, if Polanco committed a fourth costly error or misplay because Baldelli kept running him out there.
Baldelli has done plenty of questionable things in his career. He made plenty of questionable calls in that series. Let’s be careful in crowning him because Lewis, Lopez, Gray, Correa and a nails bullpen carried him to one wild card series win against a Blue Jays team that looked lost. He needs to show me more.