What makes you believe that either Kepler or Harrison are better outfielders? Walker is faster than both and just because Kepler plays CF doesn't neccesarily make him a better outfielder. Walker produces so much more than either Harrison or Kepler on a yearly basis. Don't get me wrong - I love both Harrison & Kepler alot. However, all Walker does is lead his leagues in HRs and RBI every year. Until he proves your future projections wrong - I'll take the chosen All Star. If you're not sure what type of OF Walker is - listen to the games more. He runs and roams his position rather well. Colabello had outstanding minor league numbers and played exceptional in April, but not May (MLB). There is no exact science. But this much I know for sure: Walker Avg. 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO OBP SLG .251 08 00 13 48 104 16 66 .301 .460 Harrison Avg. 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO OBP SLG .273 17 01 01 29 76 25 41 .352 .384 Kepler Avg. 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO OBP SLG .218 05 04 02 23 53 19 29 .317 .340 Team Statistical Leaders are important, but League Leaders Win more.