B4C--I see that you have started several threads and the drift of each one is that the Twins won't spend the money to truly contend. I actually at least partially agree with you. However, retaining Justin Morneau is not a smart move to make, especially with his injury history and lack of productivity for that last three years. Run Batted In is an opportunity stat and Morneau has had more than his fair share of opportunities. He is OPSing only .745 with runners on base and an even lower .735 with runners in scoring position. With RISP and two out, he is 2-14. He has batted behind two guys that get on a lot and he hasn't produced enough to justify his contract, not even close. As I mentioned in passing, given his current salary of 15M per year, for the Twins to sign Morneau, they probably would have to propose a significant salary cut and I suspect that it would be very difficult for any player to accept that. Accepting a lower salary from another team makes more sense. Finally, you say that Morneau isn't really a power hitter. He averaged nearly 30 homers per year between '06 and '09. I consider that a power hitter. You picked out the season where Morneau hit "only" 23 homers, but you don't mention that in that same year, he had 47 doubles, giving him over 70 XBHs. This year, Morneau has ten extra base hits including just two homers with nearly 20% of the season gone. Yes, Morneau has gotten several hits, but his OPS is still only .720, hardly the kind of numbers that generate an eight-digit contract. Almost all major league players have peaks and valleys and as far as batting average goes, Morneau is riding a wave, but the other numbers still don't add up to a star player, much less an MVP contender. Add in Morneau's age and history of injuries and late-season fades and I see an extremely poor risk for a large contract extension.