I've resisted comment here on this topic because I think it's complicated. No one statistic is the magic bullet and Eddie Rosario is a big league talent, without question. It makes no sense to me to bench him, reduce his role, or diminish his playing time with two and a half weeks to go. That certainly seems to be the consensus of those posting on this thread and I agree wholeheartedly. Eddie's best skill is as a run producer. We can have the debate about the value of RBIs, but Rosario wants (I think more than most) to be the guy at the plate when a big hit will change the game and he has produced on balance. Eddie is not a patient hitter. While he is chasing less, he still gets in "swing mode" quite often and will swing at everything, usually making contact, but not often enough making solid contact. His OBP and slugging are in the average range for a corner outfielder. I see nothing in the advanced metrics that predicts that he will be better than that. Defensively, his metrics are somewhere between average and poor. My eyes tell me he's covering more ground this year in the field than he did in the second half last year, but he seems to come up short on making great defensive plays more often than not. The arm is strong, but too often the throw goes to the wrong base. Also, it must be considered how many outs he has cost on the bases. I think it is far more than the extra bases he might have taken, so his base running is also a net minus. All of these factors result in a WAR that is mediocre. Is WAR a perfect stat? I don't think so, but it tries to give a comprehensive look at the overall value of the player. Also, as noted, Rosario has diminished value since his best year, 2018. Eddie's value doesn't match his salary and the projected salary he would get as an arb-eligible player next year. The Twins have at least three players who project to be better offensive players than Eddie (Kirilloff, Larnach and Rooker) and any of them would cost pennies of the dollar compared to Rosario in 2021. I believe one or more of the three will be ready for full-time major league duty next year, and if that is the case, it is time to say good bye to Rosario.