I'm not allergic to giving players one-game pressure. The post-season, should the team get there, is all about that kind of pressure.
(For that reason, some of the logic* used to defend getting guys like Gary Sanchez, where getting him out of Yankee Stadium will turn his career around, has always seemed short--sighted. Great, we're in the post-season, now we head to... Yankee Stadium.)
A right handed hitter like Garlick, on the short side of the platoon, had better have a microwave mentality and be ready to heat up instantly.
*expressed by fans, not necessarily the FO