From a pure defensive standpoint... I wouldn't trade him for any another CF. However... he is young and some youthful mistakes can happen. He cost us a win in that game against the White Sox that you mentioned. He had plenty of time to get set. By not getting his feet set and himself in throwing position... he turned a fairly routine throw into a terrible throw, allowing the tying run to score from third. The runner had no business tagging on that shallow fly. If Buxton does it right... the runner should have been out with room to spare and the Twins could have won it in regulation. But Yeah... He's good... I wouldn't trade him for anyone defensively.