It's always a treat when one of the TD Mount Rushmore heads comes to life and talks about baseball. Out of respect, I put down my philly cheese steak Hot Pocket while reading your input, Seth. Disagree with much of what you said, though. Punto's hypothetical belief system is wrong. Sliding into first has ranked right up there with Dusty Baker's Baseclogger Theory of On Base Percentage in the pantheon of common knowledge baseball fallacies for just about forever by now. Not faster. Injuries. Bad idea. The end. Superman delusions aside, Punto also sometimes suffered from the Little League, situationally unaware 'run as fast as you can until someone tags you out' syndrome. Running out a routine grounder down 6 in the 9th is hustle. 'Digging for two' while you're 10 feet short of halfway to second when your soft infield popup is gloved is not just fake hustle, it's foolish. Also, why compare L'il Nicky to bench players? Punto put up over 400 plate appearance per season for half a decade. Whatever his label, Punto spent the majority of his Twins career as the at bat equivalent of the lefty half of a platoon, which made him just about an everyday player. And a fairly bad one at that. And he was a pretty bad almost-every-day player on a team that was expected to contend every year, not a stopgap on a rebuilder like Newman or Hocking in their 'peak' years. That made his offensive futility even more of a kick in the groin than the statistical nuisance that an actual utility player's would be. Few people would deny that Punto was a good infielder. But shortstop is the make-or-break position for utility infielders, and in that respect, well, Punto was no Jeff Reboulet. Jmo. Also, Punto wasn't even Reb's mustache, which rocked the free world: http://cdn0.sbnation.com/imported_assets/152452/jeff_2bking.jpg If Punto was really under-appreciated by the fan base, why was that? Was it because they didn't see that his uniform was dirty halfway through his warmup routine? Was it because they weren't listening to the incessant Twins spin machine's inane chatter about piranhas battling their small-ball tails off the right way while moving the runner over? Or was it because they had no energy left to appreciate him due to the enormous workload generated by frequently under-appreciating a likely future first-ballot Hall of Famer? Maybe some of each. Now that I've crossed the border between rant and diatribe, there's not much to lose by throwing in a summary. Punto probably generates criticism (including mine) out of proportion to his actual effect on the team for one basic reason. He represents an ugly byproduct of pitching to contact: overvaluing defense at the expense of offense. That, and he never lived up to the lofty stats put up by Al Newman in comic relief. Who can forget the time he knocked TC Bear out, donned his costume, ran into the stands, and bit a lady's head off?