I find it particularly troubling with the pitchers. People make grandiose claims about how Anderson is an awful pitching coach when that simply isn't the case. I don't think he's a great pitching coach but he certainly doesn't do a bad job. There are dozens of pitchers that have left the Twins since he was their pitching coach and RA Dickey is the only guy who really thrived away from Anderson. RA Dickey is also an aberration who magically figured out the knuckleball in his mid-30s after several teams gave up on him. Other than that, the "got away from the Twins and thrived" concept doesn't really play in reality. Let's take a look: Lohse is the same pitcher. We established that. Humber only pitched 20 innings in Minnesota. Eric Milton crashed and burned after leaving the Twins. Juan Rincon didn't fare much better. Matt Guerrier fell on his face but we all saw that coming a mile away. JC Romero has had good seasons away from the Twins but he also had some good seasons in Minnesota, certainly not enough of a difference to fault Anderson for screwing up. Jesse Crain is dominating hitters just like he dominated hitters in his last season with the Twins so that's another awful example commonly used to discount Anderson's coaching abilities. Grant Balfour was a good pitcher with the Twins and I was disappointed that they got rid of him too quickly. Again, not Anderson's fault. LaTroy Hawkins has bounced around and turned into a journeyman, never again matching his seasons with Minnesota. Carlos Silva became one of the worst pitchers in baseball after leaving (again, saw that one coming). Pat Neshek was out of baseball not long after leaving the team. Dennys Reyes had what were far and away the best years of his career with Minnesota. Boof Bonser was awful in his last two seasons with the Twins and was even more awful away from Minnesota. WAIT! I FOUND ONE! Luis Ayala, a career journeyman, has had a couple of really impressive seasons post-Minnesota. Rick Anderson, failure as a pitching coach, confirmed.