Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    Minnesota Twins Roster Projection 3.0


    Seth Stohs

    My stay in Ft. Myers is coming to an end with a Sunday morning flight back to Minnesota. Nick is here now, ready to report from Twins spring training.

    After spending the last eight or nine days around Hammond Stadium, talking to people, and asking questions, I felt the timing is right to do one more roster projection. The last one was done right before spring training started. There have been a few changes since then, but generally speaking, the Twins didn't have a lot of decisions this spring. Even now, there really are just a couple of decisions to make before Opening Day. It will be interesting to see how it plays out.

    Image courtesy of Brad Rempel, USA Today

    Twins Video

    Let’s start with the hitters and then get to the pitchers:

    HITTERS

    Catcher (2) - Kurt Suzuki/John Ryan Murphy - Barring injury, these two roster spots were never really in doubt. Suzuki will start the season as the team’s starter, and Murphy will be the backup.

    Depth: John Hicks is on the 40-man roster. He will head to Rochester as the Twins #3 catcher, ready when needed. Juan Centeno is not on the 40-man roster, but he has made a strong impression in spring training both with his offense and defense. Beyond that, Stuart Turner and Mitch Garver will both start in Chattanooga.

    First Base (1) - Joe Mauer - He’s the guy. His defense is solid, and hopefully his third season after his concussion will be a step forward again for him. Most important, let’s hope his eyesight and clarity is there. If so, he’s an ideal fit in the #2 spot in the lineup, able to get on base in front of Miguel Sano.

    Depth: Byung Ho Park will spell Mauer at first base from time to time. Kennys Vargas goes to AAA where he will play most every day and provide depth at first base and DH.

    Second Base (1) - Brian Dozier - No question here. Dozier earned his spot on the 2015 All-Star team and even homered in his one plate appearance. Dozier worked hard again in the offseason and obviously hopes to put together a full, consistent season.

    Depth: Jorge Polanco and James Beresford will both be at Rochester and both can play second base. Polanco has more pop in his bat while Beresford can provide singles and better defense. Both will likely move around the diamond more in 2016, making themselves more valuable.

    Third Base (1) - Trevor Plouffe - The Twins stood by Plouffe as their third baseman, and he hopes to return the favor with another strong season. He will hit in the middle of the lineup and wants to be a run producer. Defensively, he is quite solid.

    Depth: While manager Paul Molitor has said that Miguel Sano likely will not play third base this year, that obviously can change depending upon the situation. If Plouffe were to be out for an extended period of time, Sano could move back there. However, for days off and such, Eduardo Nunez will play there.

    Shortstop (1) - Eduardo Escobar - The last two seasons Escobar began the year as a utility guy. In the second half of each season, he played very well. Finally, he is getting the opportunity. He may not have great range but he makes the plays at shortstop. He has been a doubles machine as well.

    Depth - Eduardo Nunez and Danny Santana can play shortstop and all around the infield. Ryan and Molitor would likely feel quite comfortable if they needed to go to Wilfredo Tovar. Jorge Polanco would likely get the first crack should Escobar be out for an extended time.

    Left Field (1) - Eddie Rosario - The outfield isn’t completely set, but Eddie Rosario will be in it. He has played some in center, but has been in left field the majority of the time. Pitchers can count on his defense, and he showed a strong, accurate arm. Some are worried about his offense as he does not walk and swings at most everything. But, the numbers he put up in 2015 were not out of line with what he has done in the past (unlike Danny Santana who put up numbers that were unrealistic for him).

    Center Field (1) - Byron Buxton - It’s really been clear all along, at least since Twins Fest that the Twins had every intention of Buxton being their Opening Day center fielder. In the majors last year he had not put up much offense, that still appears to be the case. They will likely let him struggle some with the bat and enjoy the defense he provides in center.

    Right Field (1) - Miguel Sano - We can agree or disagree with the offseason decision to put Sano out in right field, but it is what is going to happen. I’ve said all along that I think he’ll be just fine out there. There will be a few ugly moments in the transition, but that’s all right. Big picture is that his bat is in the lineup, in the middle of the lineup.

    Depth: Max Kepler will likely be the guy promoted to start at any of the three positions.

    Designated Hitter (1) - Byung Ho Park - Heading into spring training, how Park would transition to the big leagues was one of the biggest stories. Although we shall see what happens during the regular season, no one is wondering whether or not he’ll start the season in AAA anymore.

    Bench (4) - Backup Catcher, Eduardo Nunez, Oswaldo Arcia, Danny Santana - Santana can play six defensive positions and run well. Nunez can play three infield positions, two outfield positions and did all right as a pinch hitter last year too. Arcia is the question mark still and yet there isn’t an obvious choice ahead of him. If the Twins were to unload Arcia via trade, that might open up things for Ryan Sweeney or Darin Mastroianni who can play all three positions. There is a lot of talk right now about Carlos Quentin being a possibility if Arcia were out of the picture. However, he is really limited to first base and DH spots. He would be pretty strictly a bat off the bench, which wouldn’t be a bad thing.

    PITCHERS

    STARTING PITCHERS

    Starter 1/2/3 - Ervin Santana/Phil Hughes/Kyle Gibson - No change here. These are the top three.

    Starter 4 - Tommy Milone - Milone is often overlooked because he isn’t blessed with a big fastball. However he has put together a real solid career, and another solid spring training. I’m not saying that he is the #4 starter, but I feel like he has earned a spot in the rotation.

    Starter 5 - Tyler Duffey - I’m still going to say that Tyler Duffey will start the season in the rotation, but I’m not as certain about that as I was four weeks ago. He hasn’t been bad, but he hasn’t impressed so much this spring. Then again, we know he is working on the change-up and incorporating that into his repertoire. But I don’t think it’s a 100% given at this point either.

    Depth: Trevor May was told earlier this week that he will be returning to the bullpen. On Friday, Jose Berrios was sent back to minor league. What was eight pitchers for five spots in now six pitchers for five rotation spots.

    Most Twins fans want to dismiss Ricky Nolasco as a rotation guy, but it might be a little early for that. He wasn’t good in his first outing, but he’s been all right since. His most recent start came on the minor league side and he looked quite good. If he’s got his curve ball breaking sharply and command of his fastball, he can be a solid back-of-the-rotation starter. I still think that Duffey will be in the rotation and Nolasco will go to the bullpen, but it’s not as much of a certainty as many want to believe.

    Depth: Jose Berrios will be at Rochester to start the season. He’ll have to work out his command issues from this spring, but he should be ready sooner rather than later. Pat Dean will also be in the Rochester rotation.

    BULLPEN

    Closer (1) - Glen Perkins - No change. The three-time All-Star, who has closed out wins for the American League the last two seasons and then struggled in the second halves. His command is good this spring and his slider is breaking sharply, so he should return to all-star status.

    Right-Handed Relievers (5) - Kevin Jepsen, Trevor May, Casey Fien, Ryan Pressly, Ricky Nolasco -

    Left-Handed Relievers (1) - Fernando Abad -

    Jepsen, May and Fien are givens, and Nolasco isn’t likely to be dealt. I think that Abad is a certainty to be added to the 40-man roster at someone’s expense. The elephant in the room for the Twins bullpen scenarios is Michael Tonkin. The right-hander is out of options. He has dominated in AAA, but he has struggled in the big leagues. And, he has struggled mightily this spring. At this point, he is no longer a given to be on the roster. If DFAd, it would be interesting to see if anyone claims him.

    Tonkin could get the opportunity solely due to the “Options” thing. However, Ryan Pressly has pitched well, and he was pitching well when his 2015 season came to an end due to injury last year, but it isn’t going to be an easy decision. Veteran Brandon Kintzler has had a solid spring. Taylor Rogers’ name keeps coming up over and over, so he’s definitely a possibility as a second lefty. So is Ryan O’Rourke who is in a way the incumbent and has had a solid spring.

    DEPTH - Depth comes from the names above that are sent to Rochester, but also the next wave is getting close. How many of the Nick Burdi, JT Chargois, Jake Reed, Alex Meyer, Mason Melotakis, Brandon Peterson and Corey Williams group will we see throughout 2016?

    So there you have my updated roster projection following a week in Ft. Myers. I don’t think there’s anything too surprising. There really are just a couple of jobs up for grabs.

    Let’s summarize:

    C - Kurt Suzuki

    1B - Joe Mauer

    2B - Brian Dozier

    3B - Trevor Plouffe

    SS - Eduardo Escobar

    LF - Eddie Rosario

    CF - Byron Buxton

    RF - Miguel Sano

    DH - Byung Ho Park

    Bench - John Ryan Murphy, Eduardo Nunez, Danny Santana, Oswaldo Arcia

    Starters - Ervin Santana, Phil Hughes, Kyle Gibson, Tommy Milone, Tyler Duffey

    Closer - Glen Perkins

    RH Relievers - Kevin Jepsen, Trevor May, Casey Fien, Ryan Pressly, Ricky Nolasco

    LH Relievers - Fernando Abad

    That’s a solid 25-man roster, but what’s really exciting is the depth in the organization of players who are very nearly ready to contribute.

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Marek Houston

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, SS
    The 22-year-old went 2-for-5 on Friday night, his fourth straight multi-hit game. Heading into the week, he was hitting .246/.328/.404 (.732). Four games later, he is hitting .303/.361/.447 (.808).

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    The last 2 open bench spots are becoming a little more interesting.

     

    It would be hard to let Santana or Arcia go to waivers. They would surely be picked up by someone. O. The other hand, I like what I've seen from Sweeney and Quentin.

     

    Would Sweeney and Quentin go to Rochester if they don't make the roster?

    I heard Reusse discussing Quentin with Rob Antony--he has an opt-out but it isn't until something like June. Quentin can be assigned to Rochester. I believe the opt-out for Sweeney is earlier, perhaps as early as April 1, meaning he couldn't be sent to AAA without agreeing to go. I don't think it is out of the realm to suggest that Sweeney might see a chance for a recall fairly quickly if a) Buxton starts slow or B) Santana can't handle a utility role. I still expect the Twins to keep their out-of-options position players, but it would help them if they started to hit a little bit.

    I heard Reusse discussing Quentin with Rob Antony--he has an opt-out but it isn't until something like June. Quentin can be assigned to Rochester. I believe the opt-out for Sweeney is earlier, perhaps as early as April 1, meaning he couldn't be sent to AAA without agreeing to go.

    That opt out date has not been reported anywhere for Sweeney. June 1st is actually the standard opt out date for 6+ year MLB veterans on minor league deals, so I would guess it applies to both him and Quentin. It would be rather silly to give an April 1 opt out to a player who sat out the previous season, but never say never (Bartlett).

     

    Either player could threaten to retire, of course, then if the team really wanted to keep the player, they'd have to add them to the MLB roster. I'd probably just call their bluff, though, seeing as how you would still own their rights for 2016 (meaning, they couldn't retire and go play elsewhere).

     

    That opt out date has not been reported anywhere for Sweeney. June 1st is actually the standard opt out date for 6+ year MLB veterans on minor league deals, so I would guess it applies to both him and Quentin. It would be rather silly to give an April 1 opt out to a player who sat out the previous season, but never say never (Bartlett).

    Either player could threaten to retire, of course, then if the team really wanted to keep the player, they'd have to add them to the MLB roster. I'd probably just call their bluff, though, seeing as how you would still own their rights for 2016 (meaning, they couldn't retire and go play elsewhere).

    I interviewed Sweeney last week for my final article at MetroSportsReport.com and you can read that by clicking here. He clearly doesn't see himself as a AAA ballplayer (and based on his performance so far this spring, he has a case). He elected not to play at all last year, rather than accept AAA offers, though continuing to get paid by the Cubs made that decision a lot easier than it might this season.

     

    You don't want to base too many roster decisions on spring training performances, but when it comes down to those last couple of roster spots, performance certainly is more of a factor. I would think that a guy who has shown he can hit .270 with a little pop and play all 3 outfield spots probably would be of interest to someone else if the Twins decide they don't have room for him. His problem the past couple of years has been staying healthy. Still, if your goal is to put the most competitive team possible on the field in 2016, right now it would be difficult for me to understand the Twins keeping Arcia or Santana over Sweeney.

     

    Quentin is a different thing because of his limited usefulness defensively. I can't see how the Twins keep another guy who's limited to 1B and DH. He looks like he still has something left in the tank, however, so maybe there's some trade value there, too.

    Edited by SD Buhr

     

     

     

    You don't want to base too many roster decisions on spring training performances, but when it comes down to those last couple of roster spots, performance certainly is more of a factor. I would think that a guy who has shown he can hit .270 with a little pop and play all 3 outfield spots probably would be of interest to someone else if the Twins decide they don't have room for him. His problem the past couple of years has been staying healthy. Still, if your goal is to put the most competitive team possible on the field in 2016, right now it would be difficult for me to understand the Twins keeping Arcia or Santana over Sweeney.

     

     

    Re: your "little pop" comment.  Arcia hit 11 more Home runs in his age 22+23 seasons than 31 year old Sweeney has in his 9 year MLB career.  

    My gut tells me Nolasco makes the rotation if he can not be awful the rest of the way. 

     

    As with last year, if he can just be OK he may become tradeable to an NL team once one of them has an injury.  The Twins probably won't even ask for anything in return except for them to take him and his salary.

     

     

     

     

    I interviewed Sweeney last week for my final article at MetroSportsReport.com and you can read that by clicking here. He clearly doesn't see himself as a AAA ballplayer (and based on his performance so far this spring, he has a case). He elected not to play at all last year, rather than accept AAA offers, though continuing to get paid by the Cubs made that decision a lot easier than it might this season.

    Thanks for sharing.  I doubt many guys see themselves as AAA ballplayers, particularly one who has only played one month of AAA ball in the past 8 years.

     

    But it appears Sweeney didn't secure anything more than the standard June 1st opt out.  He actually had a March 28th opt out back in his 2013 minor league deal with Boston.  His bargaining power was apparently less this year.  (And even after he exercised that opt out in 2013, he still had to settle for another minor league deal, resulting in the aforementioned month at AAA with the Cubs.)

     

    The Twins might do him a solid and release him at the end of camp, but otherwise, if he doesn't make the Twins roster, his choices will be to become a AAA ballplayer for up to 3 months at our discretion, or retire and sit out another season.

    My few amateur observations:

     

    - Any word on Milone being traded? He still has team control, solid back-end rotation arm.  He has some value, maybe a B level prospect for a team with some starting pitching injuries.  However, I like his LH arm in the rotation.  He will give us atlas 150 innings and an ERA around 4.00-4.15.

    - I think Buxton makes the opening day lineup solely based on his defense.  I would like to see him get a month or 2 in triple A to refine his batting approach.  However, we need his defense with Sano in RF and our SPs are not K guys.  It would be interesting to start the year with Rosario in CF, Arcia in LF and Sano in RF, but I think that would lead to too many runs with our SPs.

    - If Abad makes the roster who is taken off the 40 man?  Tonkin seems like a likely prospect at this point.  Maybe Strong?  If they move Dean off the 40 man, my head would explode, since we have lost Zach Jones with that move.

    - I think Presley has earned a opening day spot with his performance last year and his spring.  In fact, I could see him over taking Fien in late inning leverage positions.

    - I think O'Rourke would be an above-average LOOGY.  However, I think Molitor does not want a pitcher that can only pitch 1/3 of an innings.  Maybe a few months at Rochester to determine if O'Rourke new splitter (or was it a change up) can get some righties out.

    - I really like our infield defense.  The infield will save us some runs this year.  I would like to see the outfield employ more a shift.  I think that will protect Sano.

     

    Re: your "little pop" comment.  Arcia hit 11 more Home runs in his age 22+23 seasons than 31 year old Sweeney has in his 9 year MLB career.  

     

    When I talk about a "little pop" I'm not just talking about HRs, but XBHs in general, but that's just me.  When you factor in his defensive abilities, I'd probably still take him over Arcia at this point.

    I would very much doubt that TR would allow a 12 million dollar pitcher pout in the bullpen.  Duffey will start in AAA.  And we love showing off our reclamation projects, so Kintzler will be on the team.  I'm fine for both options, for April, as long as they pull the trigger faster than they did for Stauffer.

    On the other hand, the Twins now have the opportunity to stash two perfectly good young starters in the bullpen, thus pissing off both May and Duffey, while overpaid, mediocre veterans win at best half their starts with ERA's over 5. 

     

    When I talk about a "little pop" I'm not just talking about HRs, but XBHs in general, but that's just me.  When you factor in his defensive abilities, I'd probably still take him over Arcia at this point.

     

    His career Isolated slg% is .104

     

    These are some other Twins career IsoSlg%

     

    Danny Santana - .123

    Kurt Suzuki - .114

    Eduardo Escobar - .136




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...