They might both stink but Mullens is better than mannion. Mannion has thrown 110 passes in his entire 8 year career and mullens has starting experience. Mannion makes kirk look like tarkenton with his lack of mobility, and our terrible offensive like would probably get him killed.
Mullens has at least been here for the last two seasons. Had he not gotten hurt I would certainly have given him a better chance at giving a competent effort than mannion, who hasn’t even been on a roster since zimmer’s finale in Green Bay.
Who knows about the rookie, I guess it’s fair to give him a shot in a lost season. All I’m saying is that if Kirk could possibly be traded (and it’s still a possibility now that the season is shot), you’d have to have someone who could at least give a competent effort and I don’t think mannion is that guy and I doubt a rookie who’s never taken a snap would be either