I didn't see anyone saying he shouldn't be punished, unless I missed a post somewhere. I just have a problem with chastising someone (and I mean in the general public, not TD) for something I'm pretty sure the VAST majority of people have done at one time or another. Not saying that eliminates a reprimand, but there is a definite mob mentality when someone says something offensive and it's almost always true that some in the mob have their own skeletons...