In your original post, you did not distinguish, you simply pointed out that Twins' starters have a higher ERA from 75 pitches on. Truth be told though, I suspect you'll see something similar across the majors. Starting pitchers tend to tire as they go further in the game and hitters get better at timing them. Yes I suspect the Twins may have a higher ERA, but like others said, that has more to do with their talent than anything else. The other thing I think you are doing here is looking at this in hindsight. Gardy's job in managing the starting pitching is putting the team in the best position to win the game. The problem lies in that a pitcher might be cruising through X innings and then he suddenly hits a wall. Gardy's job is to see if that guy is getting tired and have an option ready and waiting. I didn't see the Deduno game you sighted, but I'd bet anything that Deduno got hit pretty hard that previous inning and escaped, or he was having troubles locating his spots (which Deduno in particular has issues with). Gardy did what he should do, kept him on a shorter leash. Last, I have to ask, in your first point, you suggested a 75 pitch limit. Now you are saying you want guys in longer. Is there a point to this? I agree you want your starters going 7 two or three games a week. That's a sign that you have a good staff. I don't see any of the pitchers on this staff being able to do that. Oh, and welcome aboard.