My apologies for not being more clear. My take would be, while you can't ever be sure of anything in baseball, if anything Shafer has shown he's extremely unlikely to hit. He has 1200 MLB PAs...there's a reason he was freely available. I think expecting him to succeed as the LH side of a platoon, where he will get the majority of the playing time, is unlikely in the short term, and does nothing good for the long term. I'd prefer any option other than that one.