Shields is overrated. Sure his K rate looks good but that is hugely boosted by the beginning of the season where he was striking a lot out of batters out. Since then he's been rather mediocre. You guys think Kyle Gibson has been rather bad this 2nd half? Shields is right there with him. Same WHIP but ones getting rather lucky with baserunners while the other is suffering bad luck. In fact, Gibson's underlying numbers are slightly better. Still want to trade for 21 million a year James Shields?