I don't think anyone is treating it as gospel......many are pointing out there is evidence, in fWAR, that May was actually good last year as a starter, but not that that proves that he will be. People on the "other side" are saying he sucked last year, and others are trying to say that is not true. My issue is that the Twins, once again, are doing the expeditious thing, and not playing for the most upside. No real surprise at all, frankly.