To be fair, he was a bit of a late bloomer. He had great BB and K rates but otherwise didn't look like a great hitter until he hit AAA in 1987, and in the PCL at the time, his .907 OPS that year wasn't that outstanding -- his whole team had an OPS over .800. After a cup of coffee, they had him go back to AAA the next year, and he got even better -- legitimately standing out in his league, although it appears he missed a little time due to injury? Could have prevented him from breaking into MLB much that year beyond another cup of coffee. Finally, in 1989, he was in MLB virtually the whole season, mostly as a little-used backup 3B but he did get stretches to start in April and June. He just played very poorly and/or was injured, and did a little stint in AAA in August. 1990, of course, he hit the ground running. Hard to say with the injuries, but perhaps he should gotten more MLB adjustment AB in 1988, and thus been more productive for a full season in 1989. So probably a season''s bonus, using his early career rate stats? 4-5 WAR? I don't think that's holding back his HOF case as much as the DH thing and the general steroid era effect.