Doesn't it depend on what you are basing your opinion? While I know there is an ongoing debate about this in baseball, there is not a universally accepted definition of how we define "good" in baseball, i.e. not everybody looks at the same statistics, or even primarily uses statistics. Until that happens, then everybody's assessment (mine, yours, the organization's, the media, etc) is ultimately opinion, incapable of proof to those who use a different metric upon which to base their opinion.