Thats a good question... Julia is out... Too much lipstick. If you spend anytime kissing her you'd look like a bad horror movie afterwards. All the Robert Palmer Girls? With that much lipstick... You might as well be resigned to it and take it out as a factor in your decision. Then the question becomes... 3 girls on a desert island? It sounds wonderful until reality sets in... It won't take long and you will be mowing the island...fixing the grass hut... Three times over. So yeah... Phoebe Cates for sure... If you grew up in the 80's like I did... Phoebe Cates was the most amazing thing out there. Hopefully... She likes my jokes or its gonna be a long time on the island.