Trading for Dozier doesn't guarantee them a playoff spot anymore than resigning Utley. It makes them a little more likely, but it's not chiseled in stone. That is what you typed And I agree that Dozier doesn't guarantee the Dodgers anything. However... If you feel that Dozier isn't a significant upgrade over Utley at 2B... on that we will disagree. If you feel that the Dodgers will make the playoffs anyway with Utley or Enrique... I won't argue that either cuz the Dodgers look good on paper but that type of thinking is Hubris and there is a downside to hubris. There are 8 teams with legitimate chances to grab one of 5 playoff spots in the NL next year. I'd try to get better in 2017 when the opportunity arises. Dozier guarantees none of it.. Dozier just makes the Dodgers most likely better and it's dangerous to pass up getting better because of Hubris.