Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    Twins Must Clear Infield Logjam Quickly


    Nick Nelson

    As Miguel Sano gets his rehab stint underway and prepares to return to the Twins, there is considerable focus on the imperative of getting him out of right field and back to third base.

    However, Sano is hardly the only piece that needs to be sorted out in a crowded infield situation.

    Image courtesy of Brad Rempel, USA Today

    Twins Video

    It is a rare thing when fans and analysts across Twins Territory reach a consensus on any subject, but we seem to have that on the issue of Sano's defensive position. The hazardous experiment of trotting him into the outfield needs to end, and really, it needs to happen as soon as he comes off the disabled list.

    Plouffe might miss a little time with a groin strain that he suffered on Thursday, and Byung-Ho Park may be in line for a demotion to Triple-A. These would potentially create short-term openings for Sano to escape from right field, but only that. Trading Plouffe and permanently opening the hot corner for the big young slugger should be a high priority for Terry Ryan right now.

    Unfortunately, that is just one of several predicaments that the general manager and his staff must untangle. While calls for change are rising in volume, Ryan is still in charge and this is his chance to make some smart moves and establish a clear plan for the roster going forward. But his task is not easy.

    Presently, it looks like Eduardo Nunez is going to be Minnesota's lone All-Star Game representative, even though he doesn't have a regular position. Nunez is already 29 and probably not a part of the long-term plan, but he should be playing regularly, if only on the basis of merit and bolstering trade value.

    Yet, we've already discussed the clogged situation at third base, and I can't see any good argument for starting Nunez over either of the middle infielders. Eduardo Escobar has clearly established himself as a better shortstop over the past couple of seasons, and he has been on an absolute tear in June, entering Thursday's game with a .394/.417/.727 line. He should be playing every day.

    Brian Dozier, too, has gotten it going after a slow start. Since being benched for a couple of days at the height of his slump in late May, the second baseman has rebounded tremendously, reaching base in 26 of 27 games and raising his OPS by 140 points.

    Even though Nunez lacks a true home on the field, Paul Molitor has found ways to keep him in the lineup, so it's not a big deal. The real problem is Jorge Polanco. The heralded 22-year-old prospect has shown promising signs whenever he's gotten a chance to play in the majors, with an .861 OPS and excellent plate discipline, but those chances have been few and far between, because the Twins can't find a place for him.

    Since his latest demotion to Triple-A, which coincided with Escobar's return from a hamstring injury, Polanco has hit .310/.372/.513. It continues to be blatantly obvious that he doesn't belong in the minors, especially when you consider that the Twins are running out of opportunities to send him there. This is Polanco's last option year, so next spring he'll either need to be carried on the MLB roster or lost to another club. The last thing this team wants is another Oswaldo Arcia situation, where they have to give up a former top prospect for basically nothing.

    Clearing out this logjam is undoubtedly going to require trading players away. But outside of Plouffe, these guys all have value that makes it difficult to justify losing them with no significant return. So in the scope of this rebuild, Ryan needs to find good opportunities and strike.

    Maybe Nunez will interest a contender as a versatile glove with a quality bat. Perhaps Escobar's hot streak, combined with his strong play over the past two years, will convince some team that he could be their answer at shortstop (though it's not clear that either Nunez or Polanco can play the position sufficiently). Heck, now that he has rebounded, maybe Dozier will draw some suitors, though I have my doubts about Ryan's willingness to give him up barring a huge return.

    Adding Polanco to any package – say, with Plouffe – could spice up the return. It seems counterintuitive for a team in Minnesota's position to be unloading prospects, but Polanco's option status makes this another instance where the Twins simply cannot afford to be patient and wait for his opportunity to arise.

    This much is certain, Ryan needs to be proactive and take action. The trade deadline is about five weeks away.

    If you were in the GM's shoes, what would be your approach as we head into July?

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Marek Houston

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, SS
    The 22-year-old went 2-for-5 on Friday night, his fourth straight multi-hit game. Heading into the week, he was hitting .246/.328/.404 (.732). Four games later, he is hitting .303/.361/.447 (.808).

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    Trading Plouffe would be answer but the problem is nobody is willing to take him at his cost. Nunez will be traded soon as the all star game is over. I really think they should trade Dozier now and get what ever they can for him I think his numbers are improving to point where somebody would be interested in him for the stretch run.

    That would leave you with Polanco at second and Escobar at SS and Sayno at third with Danny Santanna as your backup. Dozier in my mind doesn't fit into Twins longterm plans for this team because he will be to costly and better talent is pushing for his position. Also if Escobar doesn't work Gordon is soon to be here for longterm shortstop. I also have my doubts about Sano for the future he going to have to rededicate himself if he wants to be big time baseball star. I have doubts about that now he looks to satisfied right now and wants to play in social life. Park I think needs just at bats at major league level because he's proven he can hit triple A level in Korea. I just don't see where the Twins get much return because major league baseball clubs know that they have jettison some of this talent to keep there young talent and they know Twins will never trade any of their young talent away.

    I don't believe the Dozier situation is that difficult.  You have an inconsistent player who is playing well right now.  You trade him, get what you can for him, and move Polanco into the starting lineup.  If you can raise up the return by packaging something with Dozier, that is great, but if not, oh well.  Dozier is a similar situation to what the Twins went through with Willingham, Perkins, Hughes, and Suzuki.  In all of those other situations, the Twins held onto the player because they could not get value for them.  Well, the Twins fail to recognize that you are never going to be able to get the value for these player's max production.  But you also don't want to put yourself in a position to get nothing for them (which we have been excellent at doing).  

     

    Either sell for a lottery ticket prospect, or sell for a higher ceiling player whose value is low or get a vet at position where your depth is not great.  I can't imagine anyone is selling bullpen arms, but if you could get one, the Twins should do it.  The point is that something is only as valuable as what someone else is willing to pay for it.  We need to unload these players, and it is better for the Twins long term to get something and move on rather than being consumed with getting our preceived value for them.

     

    I would keep our pitching unless someone wants one of the starters.  I would trade Plouffe and Dozier.  I would hold onto Nunez and Escobar because that is an ok middle infield rotation and is worth more than you would get for them in a trade.  Head into next season with Sano, Polanco and Mauer in the infield and figure the rest out.  The outfield should work itself out long term but Sano at 3B should allow the Twins to get more athleticism and cover more ground.  We should, at worst, have a solid defensive outfield with the other players we have.




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...