Data makes this not a true statement, since his second half was pretty similar, if not better, to his first half, and pretty there with his career numbers. 2016 1st half: 3.75 FIP, 3.88 ERA 2nd half: 3.73 FIP, 3.41 ERA career: 3.70 FIP, 3.55 ERA He is a mediocre bullpen arm in his prime. Can he be usefull as the last guy out of a competitor's pen. Sure. So could be Kintzler (3.61 FIP/ 3.15 ERA 2016, 3.67 FIP, 3.33 ERA career). To compete, pick one and keep him at the end of your pen (got to get rid of replacement level O'Rourke, 4.11 FIP/ 3.96 ERA 2016, 4.42 FIP/4.98 ERA career, as well.) Then add 6 pitcher better than them ahead of them, if you want to build a pen that would help you contend. I'd pick Pressly because he is the younger and cheaper of the two (and his periferals are better), but Kintzler has to go, esp. if Molitor is planing to use him as a set up man. Also, where is Duffey? He could be one of these 6 arms in the pen, and he could be a real asset there... If the Twins do not trade Santana this season, when his value is relatively high and there are not too many good FAs, it will be a failure. An 103 loss team has no business trotting a 34 year old with half a UCL who would be a decent number 4 in a competitor, as their "Ace". I'd definitely put May in the rotation as well.