Is it a straight-up old school 5/5 category rotisserie league? Draft or auction? What's the keeper window? Am I a fantasy nerd yet? In a standard keeper league with keepers retained an additional year, Buxton is risky for next year because his average and power are still so far behind Kepler. Buxton's fantasy value so far is almost entirely based on steals, so how much he helps your team is going to depend on how all in you're willing to go for steals with your roster construction. That said, for a 'win now' team, Kepler is a starter in almost any league right now, while Buxton's value is almost all tied to next year and beyond.