Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

DrNeau

Verified Member
  • Posts

    913
  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by DrNeau

  1. According to the Duluth News Tribune, what do Twins want from Byron Buxton? "I have no idea", he says. But Twins chief baseball officer Derek Falvey and general manager Thad Levine decided not to bring him back, ending his season on Sept. 3. Buxton said being notified of the decision “kind of didn’t go over well” but added that he and the team have “turned the page.” Still, he said, they’re yet not on the same page. Asked if he knows what the Twins expect of him, Buxton said, “I have no idea what they want now. I stayed in Triple-A for four months. What do you expect? What can you want?” Buxton said he expects to be at TwinsFest Jan. 25-17 but added, “I won’t be as quiet as I have been.” -- So according to Buxton, he doesn't know what the Twins want. Also, he's not going to be quiet anymore. Okay. Where exactly is this guy's head right now? Is he going to sound off at Twins Fest, too?
  2. Yes, it is still a thread, and it made a significant turn when another poster injected the following concept into the discussion: It is reasonable to think that the reason for Sano's treatment is because of the color of his skin. Regarding your bullets: 1.) It has already been demonstrated that Mauer's off-season strength and conditioning program was limited to stretching and cardio, and this continued despite the Falvey Twins taking over in October 2016, and continued up until Mauer's retirement after the 2018 season. During the season, his program consisted of 90 minutes of stretching before batting practice and another hour on postgame maintenance. This is all documented. 2.) Mauer stated in 3/2014 that "all" of his leg workouts were by catching bullpens in the past. That is 10 years without lifting leg weights. Talk about a golden boy. Simultaneously, mixed in there were 5 off-seasons where training was limited. He also spent his past 4 off-seasons bypassing the team's strength and conditioning program, and instead stretching with his stretching trainer. 3.) If it is wrong, then it should not be OK that there was a double-standard. 4.) Agree. It should absolutely OK for the team to implement something for him, but it is noteworthy that it is a different standard. 5.) I can agree to that, but it should not be completely void of lifting leg weights. Mauer's were; he said so himself. 6.) Is the standard to not report out of shape? If so, one can do some cardio, stretch, lie around on mats, do some 55-lb squats and theyre' fine. I would have to disagree here. The standard is to do both strength training and conditioning. That's why it's called a strength and conditioning program. Regarding there being nothing similar, I'm not so sure about that. Again, Miguel Sano's strength has been less of an issue than his conditioning. Joe Mauer's strength was more of an issue than his conditioning.
  3. Or, in the case of Joe Mauer, according to you, it is acceptable to just say "why bother with that now" and let it slide.
  4. Absolutely - they should have done that to Mauer. I cannot disagree more about the "why bother with that now" approach being understandable. By Falvey coming out last week and saying Buxton is the "starting CF", he is dangerously approaching the continuance of this "golden boy" treatment. We don't need any more golden boys... just some good old-fashioned hard work - across the board.
  5. If the team is drawing a line in the sand for accountability, I'd like to think that race is not a factor, and that the decision is purely limited to player development. For that scenario to be true, though, it would be for Sano to be held to a higher standard because he is black, but then simultaneously refer to Buxton as the "starting Center Fielder" right after he just hit .156/0/4 and came out and publicly said how "pissed" he was at the Twins - while at a children's hospital charity event. To me, it doesn't seem to add up. I just want us to be competitive in all areas - including player development. If that means that in order to get there, there needs to be a line drawn in the sand when it comes to strength and conditioning, then so be it. I want this team to win!
  6. I just don’t want it to evolve into the idea that it is MY assertion that the different treatment is based upon race. You want to talk about it? Fine... have at it. Go ahead an insert race into the discussion, then. I didn't really think it was applicable, but if you think it is a "reasonable possibility", I can concede that it is conceivable that it race is the reason for different treatment. Those kid gloves, though...
  7. Why is it for me to explain and provide the reason of Twins having double standard here? I simply noted the obvious and well-documented different set of standards. The content I raised in the links was factual. The onus is not on me to me to explain the reason for it. The thread was created in efforts to demonstrate there is seemingly now a different standard, and then after that, to discuss. You want to know the reason why? I also would like to know the reason. "If there's a double standard, as the OP has pointed out ... address it. Otherwise, let's stop doing the praise/criticize tired old nonsense that has been done to death." Sounds like you wish to want to completely shut down the discussion until I make a claim as to the reason for all of this. It's a pretty extreme position to take, especially when I'm the only person on the whole website to even bring it up. While I cannot definitively demonstrate why these things have occurred, I can speculate why. Before I begin, I will first say that it is interesting to see you saying that Joe Mauer was "treated with kid gloves". Your words, not mine. If I were to guess, and if I were to explain on a macro-level, it is because Mauer came up as the golden boy, and received the golden treatment, and by the time the organization saw areas needed for improvement, the team had already invested $184 million in him, and decided it was worth more to the organization to ride out the Golden Boy Standard to perpetuity than to take any corrective action(s) against him. Why was he never asked tough questions by the media? Even after announcing in 2016 that he had been suffering with "blurred vision" since August of 2013, no one even asked him why he didn't tell the team. Why is that? We can only speculate. Protection of investment? Face of the Twins? Maybe every employee in the Front Office wanted to be able to brag they were close personal friends with Joe. Maybe it was carefully outlined in Pohlad's will. I have no idea. Now, with the 2018 season recently finished, Mauer retires, and our young 3B who was an all-star in 2017 is being held accountable for conditioning. I already said I welcome the change. However, regarding this supposed “change”, it is yet to be seen as to how much accountability will be enforced, or if this is simply a player on a last chance agreement, I don’t know. As I already said, if it actually is an organizational change to implement a greater level of accountability with strength and conditioning, I wonder why it took until December of 2018 to start implementing it. If the team waited for Mauer to retire before implementing these things, as you conjectured, that would be super alarming. The FO took over in fall of 2016, so if they intentionally waited 2 entire years for Mauer to retire before making organizational changes on strength & conditioning, as you suggested the possibility for, that is super weak, and sort of supports the idea that the special treatment of Mauer has significantly hurt this entire organization. PS - I don't think race really needs to come into the discussion.
  8. If someone were to earn a starting spot in spring training, they would do it by out-performing their opposition.
  9. I can accept that. I don't disagree with most of what you said. We both know that the exhibition games in spring are like a test environment. It's just the claim that spring training statistics have absolutely no value at all that I sort of take exception to.
  10. An equally extreme statement is to say that spring training performance absolutely does not matter at all. So extreme, I might add, that it does not bring much clarity. My theoretical scenario was in response to that first extreme/unclear statement. I sought to clarify that to some degree, spring training performance does matter. If Buxton were to play incredibly poor this spring, it would raise major alarms. Why would it raise alarms? Because to some degree, spring training performance does matter. You want to call the 0-for-50 scenario a straw man? Fine. Before you even responded, I asked what if he hits .156 in spring, same as he did last regular season. You chose to jump on my theoretical scenario instead. No one is being combative; please don’t insert that idea.
  11. So theoretically, in spring training, providing they passed the "eye test" of coaches, every Twins hitter could go the entire month without getting a hit, and every Twins pitcher could go the entire month without getting an out, and this would not be cause for any concern, as "result-based statistics in spring training have absolutely no decision-making value". Buxton could go 0-for-50 and you would be confident going into the regular season. You would just dismiss the whole month's worth of statistics, because they are not reliable.
  12. The person said they don't believe spring training stats matter, and that they don't know how one would earn a spot during spring training. It is not out of the realm of reason to think that statistics can be an indication of a player's performance. So...spring training stats don't matter... but stats are widely accepted and used as a tool to measure performance. Hmm... surely the argument cannot be that spring training performance does not matter at all. Right? How far will one go before that argument goes out the window? You dismiss my question about Buxton going 0-for-50. Okay, how about if he hits .156 in spring '19... same as he did in regular season '18? Would that not even be a concern? I'll tell you who is not concerned right now: Byron Buxton. He could lie on the couch for months without even standing up, cakewalk into Fort Myers and be the starting CF for the Twins.
  13. It’s good to have beliefs. For the sake of argument, if Buxton goes 0-50 with 50 Ks in spring, does that not matter?
  14. Buxton apparently does not need to earn the position. It has been gifted to him. He could have earned it by playing well and further developing in 2018, but that did not happen. He could have earned it in spring training next year, but earning a starting spot is not a requirement for Byron Buxton.
  15. From my count, Riverbrian is obtuse, hypocritical and a diva!
  16. Well, let’s respect his wishes, then. No more sugarcoating anything.
  17. Technically, Buxton said he “ain’t gonna sugarcoat nothin’”, which means he will sugarcoat it. LOL. Of the 480+ MLB players with a minimum of 90 ABs, Buxton was 2nd-worst. There was only 1 player who was more clueless than Buxton in the entire major leagues. Is it even possible to sugarcoat that?
  18. Never saw WAR broken down by team and acquisition type before. Super interesting post.
  19. Machado and Polanco up the middle?
  20. Mauer was also a grown man, and was immature in that he did not properly strength train over the course of his career. You give him a pass for that while simultaneously picking at Sano for lack of conditioning. It is demonstrated in your post above. So a big reason to dismiss my "theory" is because we have a new FO regime, which has had a thorough housecleaning in the training/fitness/medical area. News flash: They have been in control since October 2016, which effectively is about 2 years since they took any of the actions you indicated above, like firing the strength and conditioning coach and enforcing that Sano starts sending video of his workouts. Those two first years sure were cake for Mauer, though. He stretched and lifted a whopping 55 lbs! Thanks for saying my interpretation is suspect, and for bringing forth an argument which ignores the last two years Mauer enjoyed. It is no surprise and to me, just further exposes this big charade. Wave to the photographer, Joe. Wave goodbye to a lack of accountability for strength and conditioning.
  21. Yeah, but I guess it's already been decided by Falvey that he's starting. What the heck. Nice message to send to Kepler/Cave. Also, I read Baldelli is flying to personally meet with Sano & Buxton. Is he meeting with anyone else? I haven't heard that. Lot of special treatment being afforded to Buxton this week.
  22. Yeah, I don’t hear either of them sounding off to the media about how they are pissed.
  23. I loved how the Falvey Twins
×
×
  • Create New...